Japan, Full Days 4 & 5: Sumo, Samurai, Sacred Stamps, and the Search for a Fish-Free Salad

November 3–4, 2026 — Tokyo

Sometimes, a day in Japan contains an appropriate number of experiences.

And then there are days when you attempt to knock over a sumo wrestler, discover that your hotel makeup mirror has been installed at approximately belt-buckle height, encounter a subway system resembling a plate of multicolored spaghetti, and find yourself giving impromptu lessons in Shinto purification to complete strangers.

All while collecting sacred calligraphy, contemplating the remains of a shogun’s castle, and trying to find a salad that doesn’t contain fish.

Welcome to Tokyo.

November 3: Culture Day, and an Unexpected Sumo Career

November 3 is Culture Day, a national holiday in Japan, Emperor Meiji’s birthday.

And we were going to celebrate it in style.

By wrestling.

Well, not exactly.

Our first stop was a sumo demonstration, where two enormous, cheerful wrestlers introduced us to the rituals and techniques of Japan’s national sport.

Sumo, of course, is considerably more complicated than two very large men trying to push each other out of a circle.

There are ceremonial movements, precise rules, elaborate techniques, and a great deal of training behind what looks, to the uninitiated, like an extremely enthusiastic collision.

Fueled by amazing food (which they cooked for us at lunch) . . . And, if you’re in training, 10 cups of white rice per meal, per day.

The wrestlers demonstrated various holds, throws, and methods of upsetting an opponent’s balance.

They were astonishingly quick.

They were also funny, charming, and clearly enjoyed showing us what they could do.

Then came the invitation for volunteers.

Well.

I was the first person to step forward, and almost the only one.

After all, how often does one have the opportunity to try to knock over a sumo wrestler?

The answer, as it turns out, is that one can try as often as one likes.

Actually succeeding is another matter.

First, I attempted the obvious approach: pushing.

My hands sank into an astonishingly substantial layer of flesh, which was also extremely sweaty.

There was simply nothing solid to push against.

It was like trying to move a very large, very cheerful waterbed.

And the waterbed was considerably stronger than I was.

I pushed harder.

Nothing.

He grinned.

I reconsidered my strategy.

Now, I study iaido, not sumo, but I do understand that balance is important. And if brute force wasn’t going to accomplish anything, perhaps a little ingenuity might.

So I decided to hook his leg.

That caught him off guard!

It didn’t actually bring him down, but it certainly surprised him, and the other wrestler absolutely roared with laughter.

I considered that a moral victory.

I came away with a much greater appreciation for the skill involved in sumo, along with the realization that my future career in the sport is probably limited.

Still, not everyone can say they’ve tried to trip a sumo wrestler.

Meiji Shrine: Chrysanthemums, Archers, and a Holiday Crowd

Next came Meiji Jingū, the great Shinto shrine dedicated to Emperor Meiji and Empress Shōken.

The shrine is surrounded by an enormous wooded sanctuary, and walking toward it feels almost like leaving Tokyo behind.

Tall trees form a green corridor, and enormous wooden torii gates mark the transition into sacred space.

Along the way, we passed an extraordinary display of barrels.

But unlike the huge rack of sake barrels across from them – similar to what we’d seen at Kamakura – these were barrels of French Burgundy wine!

Emperor Meiji encouraged Japan’s engagement with Western culture, and the wine barrels commemorate that connection.

Culture Day brought special celebrations to the shrine, including traditional martial arts and archery demonstrations.

I’d particularly hoped to see yabusame, the spectacular Japanese art of horseback archery.

Unfortunately, so had approximately half the population of Tokyo.

The crowds were simply overwhelming, and there was no realistic way to get close enough to see the performance.

Boo hoo.

But we did see several archers moving through the grounds, carrying their extraordinarily long Japanese bows, or yumi.

Later, I even encountered an archer carrying a bow on the subway.

There’s something rather wonderful about seeing a centuries-old martial tradition traveling on a modern Tokyo train.

The shrine was also hosting an extraordinary exhibition of chrysanthemums.

Not merely flowers in pots.

These were living sculptures.

Some were trained into miniature trees, with thick little trunks, carefully arranged branches, and blossoms balanced above moss-covered bases.

Others were elaborate arrangements of yellow, pink, red, and white flowers, each apparently determined to outdo its neighbor.

Having visited the Shunkaen Bonsai Museum earlier in the trip, I found myself particularly interested in how these plants had been trained.

There is something wonderfully Japanese about taking a plant that wants to grow in one direction and patiently persuading it to become a work of art.

And doing so without losing the sense that it is still very much alive.

Shibuya: The World’s Largest Pedestrian Puzzle

Somewhere in all of this, Lynn and I also embarked on a quest to find a camera shop.

This sounded straightforward.

Google Maps certainly thought so.

Unfortunately, Google Maps had apparently not received the memo about the extensive construction transforming parts of Shibuya.

We followed its instructions faithfully.

Up onto elevated pedestrian walkways.

Down into underground passages.

Across intersections.

Back up again.

Through buildings.

Out of buildings.

And, naturally, across Shibuya Crossing.

More than once.

Shibuya Crossing is one of the world’s most famous pedestrian intersections, where enormous crowds cross in every direction simultaneously.

It is an astonishing sight.

It is also a particularly interesting place to find yourself when you’re not entirely sure which direction you should be going.

At some point I remembered Baraka, the extraordinary 1992 film by Ron Fricke that H loved.

It’s a film without dialogue, composed of remarkable images from around the world set to music: nature, cities, religious ceremonies, human movement, and even Japanese snow monkeys.

The great urban crowds of Tokyo were also included in a kind of visual symphony.

Although I suspect the filmmakers would have preferred not to include two increasingly exasperated women trying to find a camera store.

By the time we’d finished our expedition, we’d walked approximately 11,000 steps.

And that was just the camera-shop adventure.

I am beginning to suspect that Tokyo measures distances differently from the rest of the world.

And then we had to find our way back.

The Ginza Line.

The doggone Ginza Line.

After another expedition through Tokyo’s subterranean labyrinth, we FINALLY found it.

Once on the subway, feeling rather pleased with ourselves, Lynn and I began discussing the evening ahead.

We had bought wine the night before, and were very much looking forward to returning to the hotel, putting our feet up, and polishing it off.

A lovely, quiet evening.

Well deserved, I thought.

And then my phone buzzed.

A text from Utako-san.

“Where are you? We are going to the welcome dinner.”

Lynn and I looked at each other.

WHOOPS!

The welcome dinner.

The dinner we had completely forgotten.

The dinner that was, apparently, happening RIGHT NOW.

So much for the wine.

We quickly obtained the restaurant’s address, figured out where we needed to go (luckily, the subway stop was on the Ginza Line!), and set off.

More walking.

More navigating.

More Tokyo.

And somehow, after all of that, we arrived at the restaurant before anyone else.

I have no idea how we managed it.

But I feel that should count as some sort of travel achievement.

A Lovely Welcome Dinner, and Thirteen Travelers

Our group was now complete: thirteen travelers.

The dinner was lovely, and it was an opportunity to begin getting to know the people with whom we’ll be sharing the next several weeks.

There’s something rather interesting about the beginning of a group journey.

Everyone arrives with their own histories, personalities, expectations, and reasons for traveling.

For the moment, we’re thirteen individuals.

Over the coming weeks, we’ll become something else.

A traveling little community.

And Lynn and I, despite our spectacular failure to remember the dinner, had managed to arrive first.

Which is perhaps the most astonishing part of the entire Shibuya adventure.

A Golden Beer, a Golden Carrot, and a Healthy Denny’s

Tokyo also has a marvelous ability to surprise you with architecture.

At one point we passed the Asahi Beer headquarters, where the tall golden building is designed to resemble a glass of beer, complete with a foamy head.

And next to it is an enormous golden object.

A carrot?

A flame?

Something considerably less printable?

Officially, it’s the Flamme d’Or, or Golden Flame, designed by Philippe Starck to represent the burning spirit of Asahi Beer.

Unofficially, it has acquired some rather less dignified nicknames.

I think I’ll stick with Golden Carrot.

 then there was Denny’s.

Yes, Denny’s.

But not quite the Denny’s we know.

Apparently, Japanese Denny’s is promoting itself with a wellness initiative.

In America, Denny’s tends to conjure images of enormous breakfasts, late-night pancakes, and food that is not generally marketed as a pathway to optimal health.

But here in Japan?

Denny’s × Wellness.

Who knew?

And while we’re on the subject of Tokyo’s unexpected architecture, I must mention another building we passed.

Its balconies looked like enormous teacups attached to the outside of the building.

Blue, white, and red teacups, stacked one above another.

I have no idea what architectural problem this was intended to solve.

But it certainly made the building memorable.

Asakusa After Dark: A Temple in Technicolor

After dinner, we headed back toward Asakusa.

Lynn had visited the area on her previous trip to Japan and remembered enjoying the shops and streets around the temple.

What surprised us was how close it actually was to our hotel.

Not necessarily a straight line, mind you.

More of a great big L.

But suddenly a place that had seemed like a separate excursion was practically in our neighborhood.

And we had arrived on a very special evening.

Because it was Culture Day, Sensō-ji Temple was illuminated with a spectacular projection-mapping light show.

The enormous Hōzōmon Gate, guarded by two fearsome Niō figures, had become a canvas for shifting colors, images, and patterns.

The ancient architecture seemed to come alive.

Even Utako-san said she’d never seen anything quite like it.

There were crowds everywhere, cameras and phones raised toward the illuminated buildings.

And there we were, watching a centuries-old Buddhist temple transformed by twenty-first-century technology.

Japan seems quite comfortable placing the ancient and modern side by side.

Sometimes literally on top of each other.

We resolved to return the following morning, when we could see the temple properly in daylight.

A Brief Architectural Complaint

Before moving on to November 4, I must mention our hotel room.

Specifically, the mirror.

There is a small, round “makeup mirror” mounted on the wall.

A very attractive little mirror.

Unfortunately, it has been installed at approximately the height of my belt buckle.

This presents certain practical difficulties.

For example, applying makeup generally requires being able to see one’s face.

On the other hand, the shower is magnificent.

It’s tall enough for me, which is already a major accomplishment, and has THREE adjustable sprayers along the vertical stem, plus a handheld wand.

So apparently the bathroom designer was very concerned about the proper distribution of water over the human body.

Just not about the location of the human head.

One must take one’s victories where one finds them.

November 4: Drums, Dragons, and the Ghost of a Shogun

Back to Sensō-ji: An Unexpected Teaching Career

We returned to Sensō-ji the following morning.

In daylight, the temple was every bit as impressive as it had been under the lights.

The enormous red lantern at Kaminarimon, the Thunder Gate, is one of Tokyo’s most recognizable sights.

It was donated by Kōnosuke Matsushita, the founder of Panasonic, after he recovered from an illness. A remarkable expression of gratitude.

We also saw the five-story pagoda, the richly decorated main hall, and beautiful painted ceiling panels.

Sensō-ji traces its origins to a wonderful legend.

In 628 CE, two fishermen brothers pulled a small statue of Kannon, the Buddhist bodhisattva of compassion, from the Sumida River.

They returned it to the water.

And caught it again.

And again.

Eventually, a local village leader recognized its significance, and the statue became the sacred object around which the temple developed.

We saw a painting illustrating the story.

I had another important mission here.

Goshuin!

Having inaugurated my collection in Kamakura, I was now becoming positively enthusiastic about acquiring these beautiful calligraphic temple and shrine inscriptions.

At Sensō-ji I received two goshuin, including a special two-page inscription.

The process involved leaving my book and receiving a numbered chit so I could return to collect it.

And while waiting, I found myself at the fantastic dragon-headed purification fountain.

Now, thanks to Utako-san’s earlier instruction, I knew how to perform the purification ritual correctly.

Rinse the left hand.

Then the right.

Pour water into the left palm to rinse the mouth.

Rinse the left hand again.

And finally clean the ladle handle, allowing all the used water to fall outside the basin.

Simple enough.

Except that apparently I had acquired an audience.

There were a LOT of Western visitors around the fountain.

And after watching me, people began asking whether I could show them how to do it.

Again.

And again.

And again.

FOUR TIMES!

I had apparently become the unofficial instructor at the Sensō-ji Handwashing Academy.

I was eventually obliged to interrupt my teaching career because I needed to retrieve my goshuin.

Which led to another encounter.

A couple noticed the numbered chit in my hand and asked what it was for.

I explained the goshuin tradition.

They were on their very first day in Japan and had never heard of it.

They were intrigued.

So I took them over to the goshuin counter while I collected my book and showed them how it worked.

Another set of converts!

At this rate, the temples may have to start paying me.

Taiko: Jazz You Can Feel in Your Heart

Our next adventure was taiko drumming.

(Though first, we had to be fortified by small steaming-hot muffins filled with red bean paste.)

Lynn had done this experience on her previous visit to Japan, so she elected to stay behind while I went with the group.

Taiko drums are traditional Japanese drums, played with wooden magnolia-wood sticks called bachi. They come in various sizes, and the larger ones produce a sound that you don’t merely hear.

You feel it.

Our instructor was a young woman who had been playing taiko since she was six years old. Her mother was also a taiko drummer, so this was something she’d grown up with. Nearly twenty years of practice, and she was still a young woman.

She taught us some of the basics: how to stand, how to hold the sticks, how to strike the drum, and how to coordinate our movements with the rhythm.

There is considerably more to this than simply hitting something very large with a stick.

And she gave us a performance.

She positioned herself among three drums, moving between them as she played.

I was transfixed.

The only comparison I can make is to improvisational jazz.

Not the sort of jazz that seems determined to prove how many discordant notes can be played simultaneously.

I’m talking about the kind of jazz that makes you want to close your eyes and simply let the music flow through you.

The rhythms built, shifted, and answered one another. Sometimes delicate, sometimes powerful, sometimes almost conversational.

She moved among the three drums with extraordinary fluidity, creating something that felt both spontaneous and completely assured.

And the sound!

The largest drum produced a deep resonance that seemed to travel straight through my chest.

The music wasn’t merely flowing around me.

It was flowing through me.

Literally.

I could feel the drum reverberating in my heart.

I’ve heard taiko before. I’ve admired the precision, the energy, the spectacle.

But I had never experienced anything quite like this.

It was magnificent.

And it reminded me that sometimes the most extraordinary cultural experiences aren’t necessarily the largest or most elaborate.

Sometimes they’re a young woman, three drums, and nearly twenty years of devotion to an art.

The school also makes beautiful traditional portable shrines, or mikoshi, carried during Japanese festivals.

One of these was on display, richly decorated in black and gold

I found the connection fascinating.

The drums provide the pulse of a festival, while the mikoshi carries the sacred presence through the streets.

Sound, movement, craftsmanship, and religious tradition all woven together.

And another example of how Japanese culture preserves things that are meant to be experienced, not simply admired behind glass.

The Imperial Palace East Gardens: Where the Shogun Once Ruled

Next came the Imperial Palace East Gardens.

Although the name suggests the residence of Japan’s emperor, the history of this particular place begins with the Tokugawa shoguns.

These gardens occupy part of the former Edo Castle, the political center of Tokugawa Japan.

My First Eki Stamp! (Finally!)

There was another small milestone at the Imperial Palace East Gardens.

My very first eki stamp!

Well, technically, it was a kinen stamp, a commemorative stamp from a tourist attraction rather than a railway (“eki”) station. But I’ve been calling these “eki stamps”, and I’m not about to let technicalities interfere with my enthusiasm.

Especially because I finally had a use for the orange book from Dawn.

My friend Dawn, whose son lives in Japan, had given me this peculiar little book years ago, and for some reason I’d kept it all this time. I wrote a bit about it HERE. It isn’t an ordinary notebook. Its pages folded out in an accordion-like arrangement, almost like origami.

I’d never quite known what to do with it.

My collecting career, however, had gotten off to a rather unimpressive start.

At the Tokyo National Museum, there had apparently been THREE different stamps available.

Three!

Two of the women in our group had collected all three, although they hadn’t realized there was any particular significance to them. They’d simply thought they were fun things to stamp on paper.

Meanwhile, I had actually looked for the stamping station.

And missed it completely.

Drat.

So while my goshuin collection had been progressing beautifully, my orange accordion-fold book remained stubbornly unstamped.

Until today!

At the Imperial Palace East Gardens, I finally found a commemorative stamp and made my very first impression.

It wasn’t quite the spiritual experience of receiving my first goshuin at Kamakura, but it was enormously satisfying.

A little ink, a little paper, and a book I’d somehow kept for years finally finding its purpose.

And I am now officially on the lookout for stamping stations.

Preferably ones I can actually find.

Edo Castle: What Fire Couldn’t Destroy

The great castle keep was destroyed in the devastating Meireki Fire of 1657 and was never rebuilt.

But the enormous stone foundations remain.

And enormous is definitely the word.

I was immediately reminded of Sacsayhuamán, the extraordinary Inca stonework above Cusco, Peru.

Different cultures. Different construction techniques.

But the same astonishing ability to fit huge stones together with extraordinary precision.

Some of the castle stones are cracked, and Utako-san explained that the cracks were caused by fire damage.

Imagine the heat required to damage stones of that size.

The corners of the walls flare outward in a distinctive way, creating massive, sloping foundations for buildings that no longer exist.

We also saw a model showing what the original castle keep looked like.

Standing beside the surviving foundations, it was difficult to imagine just how enormous the original structure must have been.

And yet, where the shogun’s tower once dominated the landscape, a beautiful tree now grows.

There’s something rather wonderful about that.

The castle is gone.

The shoguns are gone.

But the tree is doing very nicely, thank you.

Pines, Chrysanthemums, and a Garden Inside a City

The gardens themselves were extraordinary.

Beautifully shaped Japanese black pines spread their branches in carefully balanced forms.

Some leaned over ponds, their reflections almost as beautiful as the trees themselves.

There were camellias just beginning to bloom, with hundreds of tightly closed buds promising an extraordinary display in the coming weeks.

Not dozens.

Hundreds.

The plants seemed to be waiting for just the right moment.

And then there were the chrysanthemums.

Oh, the chrysanthemums!

These were not ordinary potted flowers.

They were extraordinary horticultural constructions, trained into great cascading arrangements called kengai-zukuri, or cliff-style chrysanthemums.

And here’s the astonishing part.

Each enormous cascade can be created from a single plant.

One stem, carefully trained and branched over a framework, eventually producing what looks like an entire waterfall of flowers.

The amount of patience and skill involved is almost beyond imagining.

It’s rather like bonsai, except that the final result is a glorious explosion of blossoms.

And then there was the garden itself.

A pond, sculpted trees, carefully placed rocks, and beautifully composed views.

Beyond the trees, modern Tokyo rose in glass and steel.

That juxtaposition seems to be one of Japan’s great gifts.

You can stand in a landscape designed to evoke centuries of quiet contemplation, while an enormous modern city continues its business just beyond the trees.

And somehow, both belong.

H is Here.

There is something else I haven’t mentioned yet.

At every temple we’ve visited, it seems that just as I arrive, a crow or raven settles into a tree above me.

Every single time.

Those who knew H will understand why this matters.

Ravens have long been one of the symbols I associate with him.

And here I am, halfway around the world, visiting places I’ve dreamed of seeing, and repeatedly hearing or seeing that familiar black bird overhead.

I even managed to photograph one.

I don’t need to explain it further.

H is here.

An Exhausted Foot, a Grocery Store, and Ten Suspicious Salads

By midafternoon, my foot had had quite enough.

Even with wrapping, bracing, and every effort to be sensible, the cumulative walking was catching up with me.

At approximately 3:30, I declared the day’s sightseeing officially concluded.

I was IN.

But first, dinner.

After a taxi ride home from the Gardens with Linda, with a driver that insisted that we were staying at the exact wrong hotel (thankfully Linda had our actual correct hotel’s business card), I collected Lynn, and we made another expedition to the neighborhood grocery store.

This has become something of a ritual.

And I have discovered that Google Translate is one of the greatest inventions in the history of international travel.

Because buying food in Japan when you cannot eat fish is an adventure all its own.

You would think a salad would be safe.

Ha!

Apparently, fish can find its way into almost anything.

Dashi. Bonito. Fish extracts. Fish sauce.

Even a perfectly innocent-looking vegetable salad may have a surprise lurking in the ingredients.

So I stood there with my phone, translating one label after another.

And another.

And another.

I must have investigated ten different salads before finding two that appeared to contain no fish whatsoever.

One turned out to be a cold acorn-squash salad.

The other was essentially a selection of pickled radishes.

Not exactly what I would have predicted for dinner in Tokyo.

But no fish.

SOLD.

I added an egg-salad sandwich, a red bell pepper, an orange, and, naturally, a bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon.

A perfectly respectable international dinner.

And then we went home.

Tokyo, in All Its Contradictions

Looking back on these two days, I’m struck by how many different versions of Japan we’ve encountered.

Enormous sumo wrestlers and exquisitely trained chrysanthemums.

Archers carrying ancient weapons through modern subway stations.

A seventeenth-century castle reduced to stone foundations, surrounded by one of the world’s largest cities.

A temple illuminated with digital projections one evening, then filled with people quietly performing centuries-old rituals the next morning.

And a foreign visitor who came to collect a little sacred calligraphy and somehow ended up teaching handwashing.

There’s also the reality of travel.

Feet get tired.

Maps become confusing.

Hotel mirrors are installed in inexplicable places.

And sometimes dinner is a collection of supermarket discoveries eaten in your room.

But perhaps those are the things that make a journey feel real.

Not just the monuments, the ceremonies, and the extraordinary sights.

The little surprises.

The people.

The unexpected connections.

The moments when something you’ve read about or practiced at home suddenly becomes part of your day.

And the occasional enormous wrestler who discovers that the tall American woman is willing to try a leg hook.

Tomorrow, we leave Tokyo and head for Hakone.

I suspect there will be more stories.

But for tonight, my foot is resting, my Cabernet is poured, my suitcase is in the lobby waiting to be whisked away to Kanazawa, and I’m quite content to let the sumo wrestlers have the last word.

After all, I may not have won the match.

But I certainly surprised the competition.

I never get a percentage from any links I include – but! – if you are curious about Overseas Adventure Travel and want $100 off, call them at 1-800-955-1925 and request their amazing catalog, tell them you were referred by Sandy Shepard, customer number 3087257, and get $100 off your first trip! The catalog is what all good dreams are made of!

Japan, Full Day 3: 1st Beginnings, Small Remembrances, & A Very Large Buddha

Monday, November 2, 2026 — Kamakura

There is something particularly Japanese about a day that begins with the crush of the subway, contains a gigantic Buddha and a Shinto wedding, and ends with rain.

Of course, there is also something particularly Sandy about a day involving ancient shrines, a rather enthusiastic international game of charades, thousands of small stone figures, fierce Buddhist guardians, and a warning about predatory birds.

But I’m getting ahead of myself.

Kamakura: Samurai History, with a Chance of Rain

Today’s excursion was optional, and the weather forecast was decidedly unenthusiastic.

Rain. More rain. Possibly rain accompanied by additional rain.

So the elegant haori stayed behind, and my trusty REI rain jacket came out to play.

Our destination was Kamakura, the seaside town south of Tokyo that became the center of Japan’s first warrior government in the late twelfth century.

For someone studying iaido, this is rather like visiting a place where the history you’ve been reading about suddenly stops being theoretical.

The Kamakura period saw the rise of samurai political power, the spread of Zen Buddhism among the warrior class, and the creation of some of Japan’s most extraordinary swords.

I was already interested.

The weather, meanwhile, remained determined to provide atmosphere.

Children, Weddings, and My Very First Goshuin

Our first stop was Tsurugaoka Hachimangū, Kamakura’s magnificent Shinto shrine, founded in the eleventh century and closely associated with the Minamoto clan and the Kamakura shogunate.

The buildings were glorious: brilliant vermilion pillars, elaborate painted eaves, broad stone stairways, and a wonderful sense of ceremony.

And ceremony, as it happened, was very much on the day’s agenda.

We encountered children dressed in beautiful traditional clothing for Shichi-Go-San, the Japanese celebration marking important milestones for children at ages three, five, and seven.

Little girls in gorgeous kimono, looking both splendid and occasionally rather overwhelmed by the attention. Parents and grandparents arranging photographs. Everyone celebrating the fact that these children were growing up.

Then we encountered an actual Shinto wedding.

The bride wore traditional white wedding attire, the groom formal black clothing, and the ceremony included attendants in elaborate robes, musicians, ritual objects, and offerings.

It was a privilege to see something so personal unfolding in such a public, historic place.

Nearby, a young Shinto priest in vivid yellow robes carried a purification wand adorned with white paper streamers. I photographed him repeatedly, fascinated by the formality of the clothing and the deliberate precision of the ritual.

And then came my own tiny ceremonial milestone.

I’d brought along a brand-new goshuinchō, the special book used to collect goshuin—calligraphic inscriptions and stamps received at Japanese shrines and temples.

I presented it to the woman preparing the inscriptions.

She opened it.

She looked at the completely blank pages.

And then she looked at me.

Through a combination of enthusiastic pointing, elaborate gestures, and what I can only describe as heavy international miming, I managed to communicate:

THIS IS MY FIRST GOSHUIN.

Not merely the first one in this particular book.

MY FIRST GOSHUIN EVER.

Her face lit up.

She seemed genuinely delighted that she was going to be the person to inaugurate my collection, and apparently added something special to commemorate the occasion.

I don’t yet know precisely what she wrote, but the pleasure she took in doing it needed no translation whatsoever.

There is something lovely about that.

A little girl celebrating a milestone. A couple beginning a marriage. And a foreign visitor, through the universal language of pointing and exaggerated facial expressions, beginning a collection of sacred calligraphy.

All in the same shrine.

Sake, Sacred Ropes, and Divine Customer Service

There were other things to learn at Tsurugaoka Hachimangū.

Stylized pigeons at the top of the plaque

For one – pigeons! At the main entrance, they appeared in the decoration above us, and Utako-san explained their significance. They are considered sacred messengers of Hachiman, the Shinto deity closely associated with warriors and the Minamoto clan, which established the Kamakura shogunate.

In fact, the characters for Hachiman on the shrine’s magnificent name plaque incorporate stylized ones at the top.

So here I was, an aspiring samurai (well, an aspiring iaidoka, anyway), standing beneath the symbolic messengers of the samurai’s protective deity.

Rather a nice welcome.

For another, an impressive display of enormous sake barrels, stacked in neat rows and decorated with beautiful Japanese labels.

These are kazaridaru, ceremonial barrels representing sake offerings made to the Shinto gods (kami) by breweries and other donors. Sake isn’t merely something to drink here; it also has an important ceremonial role.

Then there were the sacred ropes, called shimenawa, with their dangling zigzag paper strips, or shide.

Utako-san explained the imagery: the rope represents clouds, while the white zigzags represent lightning. The rope marks the boundary of a sacred space, separating the ordinary world from the realm of the gods.

Which made the fact that we were standing beneath actual rain clouds rather appropriate.

Utako-san also gave us a practical lesson in how to behave at a Shinto shrine.

First, purification at the temizuya, the stone water basin.

There is a definite procedure, and it is considerably more complicated than simply washing your hands.

Take the ladle in your right hand and rinse your left. Switch hands and rinse your right. Pour a little water into your left palm, bring it to your mouth, rinse, and discreetly spit the water out. Rinse your left hand again, then tip the ladle upright so the remaining water runs down its handle, cleaning it for the next person.

And, importantly, all the used water goes onto the pebbles outside the basin. NOT back into the clean water!

Having mastered this elaborate aquatic choreography, we were ready to pray.

That, too, has a procedure.

Toss a coin into the offering box. Bow twice. Clap twice. Make your prayer. Then bow once more.

Utako-san explained that it was perfectly acceptable to tell the gods your name and where you lived, so they would know who was making the request.

Or, she added helpfully, perhaps mentally add your phone number so they could find you.

I rather liked the idea of divine customer service.

Although I wasn’t entirely sure whether the gods accepted text messages.

The Great Buddha: Immovable Serenity

Next came Kōtoku-in, home of the Great Buddha of Kamakura.

The Daibutsu is an enormous bronze representation of Amida Buddha, dating from the thirteenth century. At approximately 11.3 meters tall, excluding its pedestal, it is one of Japan’s most famous Buddhist images.

And photographs really cannot prepare you for the scale.

He sits outdoors, surrounded by wooded hills, his enormous hands resting in meditation and his expression utterly composed.

Visitors come and go. Umbrellas bob. Cameras click. Groups arrange themselves on the steps for photographs.

And the Buddha simply sits.

The statue originally stood inside a great hall, but the building was destroyed centuries ago. The Buddha survived, and now sits beneath the open sky.

I particularly loved seeing him from the side, where the immense folds of his bronze robe and the proportions of the sculpture become even more remarkable.

Naturally, we took the obligatory group photographs.

Because no matter how spiritually significant a monument may be, someone must eventually say, “Everybody squeeze together!”

I loved the sandals that local schoolchildren had made for “their” Buddha. (It’s hard to tell from this photo, but they are definitely big enough for this Buddha’s feet – yards and yards and yards of hemp!)

Our final stop, Hasedera Temple, brought us into an entirely different emotional landscape.

Hasedera is a beautiful Buddhist temple set into a hillside, with gardens, stone stairways, bamboo, and views toward the sea.

But one of the most affecting sights was a collection of hundreds upon hundreds of small stone Jizō figures, standing in tightly packed rows.

Some were almost entirely covered with moss and lichen. Others still had clearly defined faces. Some seemed to be smiling; others looked solemn.

At first glance, they were simply beautiful in the rain.

Then Utako-san explained what they represented.

They were memorials for children who had died.

These are connected with mizuko kuyō, a Japanese Buddhist memorial practice for children lost through miscarriage, stillbirth, abortion, or death in infancy.

Jizō Bosatsu is a compassionate Buddhist figure particularly associated with protecting children and guiding vulnerable souls.

And the memorials at Hasedera are not simply a collection of ancient statues.

More than 50,000 Jizō figures have reportedly been dedicated there since World War II.

Think about that for a moment.

The little figures we were looking at were not necessarily centuries old. Families have continued to dedicate them in living memory, and the temple periodically replaces older memorial figures as new ones are offered.

Each may represent a child, a family’s grief, a prayer, or an act of remembrance.

The rows are not just an accumulation of stone.

They are an ongoing expression of love and loss.

I looked at my photographs afterward and found them much more poignant than I had realized at the time.

The rain had darkened the stone, and the moss made some of the little figures seem almost to be disappearing into the hillside.

Yet there they stood, shoulder to shoulder.

Remembered.

Nearby was a round-faced, smiling Jizō figure, hands pressed together in greeting.

This is Nagomi Jizō, a comparatively recent addition to the temple, intended to offer visitors a sense of peace and reassurance.

I couldn’t help smiling back.

Perhaps that was precisely the point.

Elsewhere in the temple grounds, hundreds of small wooden prayer plaques hung together, each bearing someone’s handwritten wish.

These are ema, votive tablets on which visitors write prayers, hopes, or thanks before leaving them at the temple.

Some were written in Japanese, others in languages from around the world. Some asked for health, happiness, or love. Others offered prayers for peace.

I found myself thinking how extraordinarily alike we all are in what we hope for, regardless of where we come from or what language we use.

And there was something touching about seeing all those individual wishes hanging together, waiting to be heard.

Bamboo, Stone Steps, and Surfers

Hasedera also has some of those wonderful little passages that seem to lead somewhere important without bothering to announce where.

Stone steps climbed through dense greenery. Bamboo rose in elegant columns. Everything smelled wonderfully alive in the damp air.

And then, from an overlook far atop many, many slippery, uneven sets of stairs, I could see the sea.

With surfers!

Somehow, with all the temples, ancient warriors, and Buddhist imagery, I had temporarily forgotten that Kamakura is also a beach town.

There they were, bobbing patiently in the gray water, waiting for waves, apparently unconcerned that the rest of us were dressed for a minor monsoon.

I rather admired their optimism.

The Fierce Ones—and Acala

In the temple and on the grounds were many amazing statues, including a huge Kannon, and bronze figures of fierce Buddhist guardians.

Armored bodies. Weapons. Terrifying expressions. Elaborate halos of flames.

They were magnificent.

Some stood over subdued figures representing forces they had conquered. Nothing about them suggested that enlightenment was necessarily a gentle process.

And here’s where the day took an unexpectedly personal turn.

I’ve been designing my second custom iaito, the companion to Lady Nene, and have named it Acala.

Acala is the Sanskrit name for Fudō Myōō, the Immovable Wisdom King of Japanese esoteric Buddhism.

Fudō is typically depicted holding a sword to cut through ignorance and a rope to bind destructive forces.

The guardians we saw weren’t necessarily Fudō himself, but they belong to the broader Buddhist tradition of fierce protectors.

Their frightening appearances are not meant to represent cruelty.

Rather, they express the determination to overcome obstacles, protect the vulnerable, and defend the path toward enlightenment.

There is something deeply appealing about the idea that compassion need not always look gentle.

Sometimes it wears armor.

Sometimes it carries a sword.

I must interrupt the spiritual contemplation for an important public-service announcement.

BEWARE OF KITES.

That was the actual wording on a wooden sign.

Kites. Large birds of prey.

Apparently, they have developed a successful business model involving swooping down from behind unsuspecting tourists and stealing their lunches.

The sign explained, rather soberly, that their sharp claws might injure you.

There was even a wonderfully dramatic illustration of a bird descending upon its victim.

Japan: where even the wildlife comes with carefully worded instructions.

This brought on a smile, although I suspect anyone who has lost a sandwich to an airborne bandit might disagree.

The Temples in the Rain — and the Demons on the Roof

By the time we reached Hasedera, the rain was not merely a gentle Japanese drizzle. Water ran from the enormous upturned tile roofs.

The roofs.

Guarded by the fierce, almost comical faces staring down from their eaves. These are onigawara, traditional Japanese ornamental roof tiles, often depicting demons or fearsome protective spirits intended to ward off evil.

And I actually knew something about them!

At home, I’ve been watching a wonderful Japanese documentary series, I believe from NHK, about traditional craftspeople and the extraordinary skills being preserved across generations. Episodes have explored everything from thatching roofs to textiles and other endangered crafts.

One particularly memorable episode followed a man, perhaps in his fifties, who had inherited his family’s traditional roof-tile-making craft.

The program showed him making these very sorts of demon faces by hand, working the clay into extraordinary expressions before firing the tiles.

So there I was, looking up at the finished work of a craft I’d watched being practiced thousands of miles away.

And suddenly those funny, fierce faces weren’t simply architectural decorations.

They represented someone’s hands, someone’s training, and generations of accumulated knowledge.

There’s a Japanese term for the artisans who specialize in making these tiles: onishi, or “demon masters.”

Which is a rather magnificent job title.

I photographed the faces while trying to shield H’s poor camera from the rain.

And it occurred to me that Japan seems to have an extraordinary number of protectors.

Fierce Buddhist guardians carrying swords. Demon faces watching from rooftops. Jizō figures watching over lost children.

Different traditions, different meanings, but all expressing, in their own ways, the very human desire to keep something precious safe.

Even if, in this particular instance, what I most needed protecting from was the weather.

Beginnings and Remembrances

Looking back on the day, I keep thinking about the contrast between our first shrine and the later temple.

At Tsurugaoka Hachimangū, we saw children celebrating the fact that they were growing older, a couple beginning married life, and a delighted shrine attendant commemorating the very first page of my goshuin book.

At Hasedera, we saw thousands of small figures dedicated to children who never had the chance to grow older.

And at Kōtoku-in, the Great Buddha sat quietly, seemingly beyond all these human beginnings and endings.

Perhaps it’s tempting to make too much of that sequence.

But sometimes travel gives you a theme without asking your permission.

We celebrate beginnings.

We remember those we’ve lost.

And somewhere between the two, we try to understand what it means to live well.

The rain made the bronze shine, the moss glow, and the temple roofs look almost alive.

And I came away with a stronger connection to the name I’d chosen for Acala.

Not because a sword should be fierce.

But because there is something deeply appealing about being immovable in one’s purpose while remembering that strength and compassion need not be opposites.

And perhaps the whole day can be captured in the seventeen syllables of a haiku:

Fierce guardians watch
The Buddha sits in stillness
A kite steals my lunch

 

I never get a percentage from any links I include – but! – if you are curious about Overseas Adventure Travel and want $100 off, call them at 1-800-955-1925 and request their amazing catalog, tell them you were referred by Sandy Shepard, customer number 3087257, and get $100 off your first trip! The catalog is what all good dreams are made of!

 

Japan Full Day 2: Cats, Calligraphy, Love Hotels, and a Very Hot Lunch

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Well, THAT was an interesting night.

Last evening’s welcome dinner was at a yakitori restaurant, where everything is grilled on skewers. Because of my finfish intolerance, I confined myself to skewers with chicken with leeks, and asparagus. What could possibly go wrong?

Apparently, quite a lot.

I suspect something fishy had previously occupied the same grill, because my digestive system decided to stage what can only be described as The Big Expel.

I spent a substantial portion of the night in the room’s “little room,” becoming much more intimately acquainted with its facilities than I had ever intended. Thank goodness for Imodium, which is rapidly establishing itself as one of my more valuable traveling companions.

Nevertheless, morning arrived, and so did I. More or less.

Into Yanaka — With Utako Leading the Way

Our destination was Yanaka, one of Tokyo’s older neighborhoods, and getting there involved a subway ride preceded by a rather elaborate journey through the streets around our hotel.

There were turns, more turns, covered shopping arcades (shōtengai), crowds of Sunday shoppers, and at least one moment when I realized that, left to my own devices, I would probably still be wandering around Asakusa looking for the correct subway entrance.

Fortunately, we had Utako-san, our wonderful guide, identifiable by her red beret and her apparently inexhaustible knowledge of how to get from Point A to Point B in a city that seems determined to provide Points C through Z along the way.

Yanaka is particularly interesting because much of it escaped both the devastating Great Kantō Earthquake of 1923 and the firebombing of Tokyo during World War II. As a result, it retains something of the character of an older Tokyo: narrow streets, small shops, traditional buildings, and a wonderfully human scale.

It was busy — Sunday, after all — but nothing like the crowds around Asakusa.

And then there were the cats.

Yanaka has become rather famous for them, both real and artistic. The neighborhood is also home to the Asakura Museum of Sculpture, formerly the home and studio of Fumio Asakura, who was particularly known for his cat sculptures.

I photographed some delightful cat-patterned kimono fabric for Basia, and then spotted a white cat sculpture perched above a shop, its tail dangling down as though it were surveying the neighborhood and finding the entire business mildly amusing.

A very catlike attitude, really.

Rice Crackers, Courtesy of Utako

At one little shop, Utako treated us to Japanese rice crackers, or senbei.

These came in a rather astonishing variety of flavors: chili pepper, matcha, sesame, seaweed, and sugar-dusted, among others.

I selected the sugar-dusted variety.

What I especially loved was seeing the woman behind the counter who had made them. There is something so appealing about buying a small treat from the person responsible for creating it, rather than picking up an anonymous package from a supermarket shelf.

And, of course, there was Utako, in her red beret, making sure we all had something tasty.

A Cemetery, a Love Hotel, and an Extremely Hasty Retreat

One of our stops was a small neighborhood cemetery, where Utako explained some of the traditions surrounding Japanese burials.

Japanese funerary practices are generally Buddhist, and cremation is overwhelmingly the norm. Families often maintain a grave that holds the cremated remains of several generations, with descendants returning to clean the grave, leave flowers, burn incense, and pay their respects.

It is a different relationship with burial grounds than the one many of us are accustomed to in the United States. Rather than being simply the resting place of one individual, a family grave can become a continuing point of connection between generations.

And then, shortly after discussing death and the ancestors, Utako introduced us to an entirely different aspect of Japanese life.

A LOVE HOTEL.

Specifically, Hotel Ai.

Now, ai (愛) means “love” in Japanese, so the name is rather wonderfully straightforward.

Utako explained that love hotels developed partly in response to the realities of Japanese housing, where several generations might live together and privacy could be in rather short supply.

After all, romance becomes a little more complicated when otōsan and okāsan — Dad and Mom — are on the other side of a very thin wall.

Love hotels provide private rooms, often with soundproofing, which couples can rent for a few hours or overnight.

Hotel Ai’s sign advertised two-hour “SHORT TIME” visits, three-hour “REST” periods, and overnight accommodations.

I particularly enjoyed the terminology.

“Rest.”

Yes, of course.

And then came the moment that made the entire stop unforgettable.

As Utako was explaining the establishment to our little group of curious tourists, a man walked out of the hotel.

He took one look at us — a group of foreigners standing outside, listening with great interest to an explanation of exactly what this hotel was for — and promptly turned on his heel and walked STRAIGHT BACK INSIDE.

WHOOPSIE.

Apparently, our educational field trip was not quite the discreet atmosphere he had been expecting.

I don’t know whether he was waiting for us to leave or contemplating a more elaborate escape route.

But I do hope he eventually managed to get out.

And Now a Commercial Break/a TikTok Production

Part of the entertainment waiting for our dinner last night was another form of entertainment — a young woman in an alley who was clearly filming some sort of TikTok video.

She was entirely absorbed in her performance, apparently oblivious to the fact that an entire group of people was waiting nearby to get into the restaurant.

There she was, doing her thing.

With her cat ears.

And her tail.

And there we were, standing patiently while the production continued.

I have no idea whether we eventually appeared as bewildered background extras in somebody’s viral masterpiece.

But I suppose there are worse ways to make one’s TikTok debut.

Back to Today, and Lunch, or: Lynn Versus the Volcano

Utako had arranged lunch at a local restaurant, and once again she worked her magic with my dietary restrictions.

My special, off-menu lunch consisted of a bowl of white rice and an absolutely ENORMOUS salad.

And I do mean enormous.

It contained green and red grapes, hard-boiled egg, melon, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, and a few pieces of grapefruit cleverly disguised as melon. I discovered those by surprise.

Several of the other women regarded my salad with what I can only describe as considerable envy.

Meanwhile, Lynn had ordered something advertised as coming with “hot pebbles.”

This turned out to be a sizzling beef dish served in a stone bowl heated to approximately the temperature of the Earth’s core.

The beef was still cooking against the inside of the bowl. The bowl itself was so hot that Lynn had to wrap the little restaurant washcloths around her hands to maneuver it.

And even then, she kept accidentally touching the sides.

There was sizzling from the beef, occasional startled reactions from Lynn, and the distinct possibility that lunch might require either oven mitts or emergency services.

I am not entirely certain whether the bowl was intended to cook the beef or the customer.

Possibly both.

Ueno Park, the Valkyries, and the Swords

After lunch, we boarded a local bus for Ueno Park.

It was slow, crowded, and full of people, but I was struck again by how considerate everyone was of one another. Even when public transportation is packed, there seems to be a remarkable awareness of the people sharing the space.

Linda (from Atlanta) and I spent the entire ride crouched over her phone, keeping track of the Valkyries/Dream game. We could only get to the live score updates, so it will be amazing to see the YouTube “best moments” later. The Valkyries managed to pull it out, in what (from our Japanese local bus, score only vantage point) seemed like a Heck of a game. Go Valkyries!

After a walk through Ueno Park, serenaded by a steel drum band playing Beethoven (!) at break neck speed, we ultimately reached the Tokyo National Museum.

Now, for someone who practices iaido, the opportunity to see actual Japanese swords — not reproductions, not photographs, but the real things — is irresistible.

Naturally, I made a beeline for the sword gallery.

There were blades hundreds of years old, displayed with extraordinary care. What is remarkable about them is how deceptively simple they can appear at first glance. A long, beautifully curved piece of steel, perhaps with only the faintest suggestion of a tempering pattern along its edge.

And yet every detail represents generations of accumulated knowledge.

One particularly beautiful tachi blade was made by Tomonari in the thirteenth century, during the Kamakura period. According to the museum, it probably belonged to Tokugawa Ieyasu, the warlord who established the Tokugawa shogunate.

Imagine that: a sword already centuries old when Ieyasu possessed it, and still here for us to admire.

The museum explained that Tomonari came from Bizen Province, one of Japan’s great centers of sword production. The blade’s graceful curvature and subtle steel pattern were lovely.


There were also magnificent sword mountings, including one with elaborate gold decoration and striking turquoise-blue accents. Another had a beautifully wrapped brown handle, with diamond-shaped openings revealing the ornamentation beneath, and wonderfully intricate metal fittings.

Given that I have spent rather a lot of time recently designing my own second iaito, Acala, I found myself examining the handle wrapping, guards, and decorative details with more than casual interest.

It is one thing to select fittings from a catalog.

It is quite another to stand in front of examples of the artistry that inspired them.

And of course, while my own swords are used for the practice of iaido rather than combat, seeing these historical blades makes the connection between our movements and their origins feel much more immediate.

The swords we practice with are not simply equipment.

They belong to a tradition stretching back hundreds of years.

But another sword captured my attention for an entirely different reason.

It was also a thirteenth-century blade, probably made by a swordsmith of the Taima school in Nara. Centuries later, it came into the possession of Ōkubo Ichiō (1818–1888), a samurai and statesman who was also a poet.

And what did he do?

He inscribed one of his poems directly onto the tang of the sword.

There it was, visible in the display: delicate gold-colored writing running along the old steel, a personal expression preserved on a weapon that had already survived centuries of history.

A sword and a poem.

Once the blade was fitted into the handle, only he would know it was there. I found that moving.

There was also a naginata blade, displayed without the long pole on which it would originally have been mounted.

A naginata is a Japanese polearm, with a curved blade attached to a long shaft. It is quite different from the swords we use in iaido, although it belongs to the same broad world of Japanese martial traditions. It was generally used by samurai women, to protect their homesteads.

Seeing the blade on its own was particularly interesting because it allowed me to concentrate on the shape and craftsmanship of the steel rather than the weapon as a whole.

Two Scrolls, Two Very Different Voices

From the swords, I moved into the galleries devoted to Japanese painting and calligraphy.

And this was another part of the museum I had particularly wanted to see.

Recently, I acquired a large hanging calligraphy scroll by Nakahara Nantenbō (1839–1925), a Rinzai Zen master who was born into a samurai family and became famous for his vigorous, almost explosive brushwork.

My scroll was painted when he was 83 years old, using traditional Japanese age reckoning.

It consists of five enormous characters expressing a famous Zen teaching:

Every Day Is a Good Day.

The phrase is associated with the Chinese Chan master Yunmen Wenyan, and its meaning is rather more interesting than the cheerful sentiment it might initially suggest.

It does not mean that every day is pleasant, or easy, or free from difficulties.

It means that each day is the day we have, and that we should meet it fully rather than insist it become something else.

Nantenbō believed that large calligraphy should be executed in a single breath, drawing its energy from the hara, the center of the body.

When you look at his work, you can almost feel that energy coming through the brush.

It is bold, immediate, and utterly unafraid of taking up space.

So I was particularly interested in seeing the museum’s own large calligraphy scrolls, some of them over six feet tall like mine, with characters that seemed to leap off the paper.

There is something thrilling about standing in front of writing that is not merely meant to be read, but felt.

And then there was the other kind of scroll.

I also recently acquired a beautiful Japanese landscape painting, almost the opposite of Nantenbō’s explosive calligraphy.

In this one, mountains dissolve into mist. Dark trees frame a tiny dwelling near the water. Two little flocks of wild geese cross a vast, open sky.

Much of the painting is, in a sense, nothing.

Empty space.

Mist.

Distance.

But that emptiness is precisely what gives it its power.

I found myself looking at the museum’s landscape scrolls, hoping to encounter something that spoke to me in the same way.

There were certainly beautiful examples.

But none quite did.

Which was rather a lovely realization, actually.

I have two Japanese scrolls at home, and they could hardly be more different.

One is all force and presence, an old Zen master throwing his entire being into five enormous characters.

The other is almost a whisper: mountains, mist, birds, and the suggestion of a world continuing quietly beyond the edges of the paper.

And somehow, I love them both.

Perhaps they represent two ways of approaching the same thing.

Sometimes we meet the world with all our energy.

And sometimes we simply become still enough to see it.

The Museum Shop — And Lynn’s Timely Intervention

Before leaving the museum, we wandered into the gift shop.

Now, most museum shops are dangerous places for me under the best of circumstances.

But this one had something especially alarming.

A ramp leading up to an entire SECOND FLOOR.

DEVOTED TO BOOKS.

Just books.

Beautifully arranged shelves and shelves of them.

I looked up.

Lynn looked at me.

And Lynn, displaying the sort of practical judgment that has probably saved us both considerable time and expense during our travels, informed me that I was NOT going up there.

Apparently, she was concerned that if I disappeared into an entire second floor of books, she might never see me again.

She may have had a point.

But I still think it was a little harsh. 🙂

A Diabolo, a Camera, and the Continuing Adventures of Technology

On our way back through Ueno Park, we stopped to watch a street performer doing astonishing tricks with diabolo — hourglass-shaped spools that spin on a string stretched between two sticks.

He sent them flying, caught them, spun them, and generally persuaded them to do things that seemed to defy several established laws of physics.

At one point he was balancing on one leg; at another he was practically kneeling, all while keeping the diabolo spinning and flying through the air.

And that enormous grin!

He was clearly having as much fun as the people watching him.

I took a whole series of photographs, and this is one occasion when I think they tell the story better together than individually.

Speaking of cameras…

You may recall that H’s camera suffered another broken protective lens filter, just as it did in South Africa.

The camera itself is fine, thank goodness, and is safely tucked into my big black puffer tote. But I need a replacement filter.

Utako actually found a camera shop near Ueno that carries them.

Unfortunately, in the excitement of the museum and everything else, we forgot to go.

We will be back in the area Tuesday.

At which point I intend to purchase TWO FILTERS.

One to use, and one to have ready for the next occasion when the universe decides that H’s camera needs another little adventure.

After a couple of subway stops and a walk back to the hotel, Lynn headed off to Don Quijote — affectionately known as Donki — in search of a replacement charging dongle for her Fitbit.

Unfortunately, she also discovered that Jim’s Android phone appears to have fallen out of an unzipped pocket.

That was genuinely upsetting.

Like me, Lynn travels with two phones: her own iPhone and the Android that belonged to her late husband. I have my Android and H’s iPhone.

These are not just spare pieces of technology.

They are little connections to people we love.

We talked about the possibility of her getting a Pixel Watch, which I have come to appreciate enormously. Google now owns Fitbit, so the transition makes some sense, and I love having notifications, Maps, Gemini, and fall detection right on my wrist.

I do still miss the elegance of my Withings watch.

But the Pixel does an astonishing number of things, and at least it doesn’t look like a petit-four strapped to your wrist.

There is that.

Tomorrow, Kamakura

Tomorrow’s optional excursion is to Kamakura, and the weather forecast is more than suggesting rain.

So the elegant haori I have been wearing will give way to my thoroughly practical REI rain jacket.

Not quite the same aesthetic, but then neither is arriving at a temple looking like a drowned rat.

Mostly, I am hoping for a good night’s sleep.

After last night’s gastrointestinal extravaganza, that would be a very welcome development.

Still, as I think back over the day — the old streets of Yanaka, the cats, the rice crackers, the cemetery, the love hotel (and its startled customer), Lynn’s volcanic lunch, the magnificent swords, the calligraphy, the quiet landscapes, the diabolo performer, and all the little mishaps along the way — I keep coming back to the words on my Nantenbō scroll.

The day certainly wasn’t perfect.

It began with a decidedly un-Zen amount of time spent in the bathroom.

But it was full of things worth seeing, learning, laughing about, and remembering.

And perhaps that is exactly the point.

Every Day Is a Good Day.

Even when some of them begin with Imodium.

I never get a percentage from any links I include – but! – if you are curious about Overseas Adventure Travel and want $100 off, call them at 1-800-955-1925 and request their amazing catalog, tell them you were referred by Sandy Shepard, customer number 3087257, and get $100 off your first trip! The catalog is what all good dreams are made of!

Japan Full Day One

Tokyo — Our First Full Day

Well, the camera filter saga continues.

No replacement yet, although H’s camera has been safely tucked away in my enormous puffer purse, awaiting a visit to a REAL camera shop.

At this point, I think the camera and I are having a disagreement about who is actually in charge.

But enough about that. We have Japan to explore!

Tsukiji: Fish, Food, and Fabulous Fungi

Our first stop was Tsukiji Outer Market, the famous Tokyo food market.

The original wholesale fish market, including its celebrated tuna auctions, moved to Toyosu in 2018, but Tsukiji remains an extraordinary maze of narrow streets, shops, food stalls, restaurants, and an indoor market area.

Fish, of course. Lots and LOTS of fish.

But also seaweed, pickles, tea, produce, kitchen supplies, beautiful knives, and all manner of things you never knew you needed until you saw them.

Our guide, Utako-san, was easily identifiable in her jaunty red beret. A very useful thing when you’re trying to keep track of your guide in a bustling Japanese market!

I was particularly fascinated by the mushrooms. So many varieties, shapes, sizes, and textures! Some looked almost sculptural. (The last photo is wasabi roots.)

I also found some special matcha for Dr. Nic, who has recently become interested in it. What better place to find something for a budding matcha enthusiast than Japan?

Lunch was at a fish restaurant, which, given my rather extensive fish allergies, might sound like an interesting choice.

Cleaning the knives after partitioning an ahi.

Fortunately, Utako-san had everything well in hand.

I was served a version of shōjin ryōri, the traditional vegetarian cuisine associated with Buddhist temples and monks.

It was lovely.

Grilled tofu, sushi made with squash and cucumber, various pickles, and other beautifully prepared little dishes.

No fish. No fish stock. No roe.

And no need to spend lunch wondering whether I’d accidentally eaten something I shouldn’t have.

A very good beginning.

Bonsai: Definitely NOT a Slideshow

Next came the Shunkaen Bonsai Museum, founded in 2002 by the internationally celebrated bonsai master Kunio Kobayashi.

Now, Lynn had visited Japan with OAT last year, and as I understand it, her group’s bonsai experience consisted largely of sitting around watching a slideshow about places in Tokyo where bonsai could be found.

Ho-hum.

I am happy to report that our experience was NOTHING like that.

We actually got to see the trees.

And what trees!

The museum is a wonderful combination of traditional Japanese buildings, beautiful gardens, a koi pond, tea rooms, and hundreds upon hundreds of bonsai, some of extraordinary age.

A view of the garden from the tea house

But it’s not simply a museum where you admire finished works of art.

It’s also a working school.

We saw apprentices carefully wiring the branches of trees, training them into the shapes that, over years and sometimes decades, will create the appearance of ancient trees shaped by wind, weather, and time.

And here’s something I found particularly fascinating: our guide wasn’t Japanese.

He was Italian.

He had been studying under Kobayashi Sensei for three years, having come all the way to Japan specifically to learn this extraordinary art from one of its greatest living masters.

Imagine that. Three years devoted to learning how to understand, shape, and care for miniature trees. More importantly, he said that three years was “barely a start.” WOW.

There was something rather wonderful about watching the apprentices at work while our guide explained what we were seeing.

These weren’t simply little trees in pots – though “bonsai” comes from “bon” (potted) + “sai” (tree). They were living works of art, constantly changing and requiring enormous patience, skill, and an understanding of how each tree naturally wants to grow.

And we were especially lucky.

Kobayashi Sensei himself was there!

He was preparing to leave the following day for a major international bonsai gathering in Curitiba, Brazil — the 15th FELAB International Bonsai Congress.

We happened to visit just in time.

Kobayashi Sensei is a legend in the bonsai world, renowned internationally for his work and for training generations of students from around the globe.

I purchased his English-language how-to book, and he personally signed it for me.

Not a bad souvenir from our first full day in Japan!

We were also given a brochure with a QR code linking to a documentary about the museum. I’m hoping to track down the link and share it here.

Three Rooms, Three Ways of Seeing

One of the most fascinating parts of the museum was its traditional Japanese rooms, where bonsai were displayed in tokonoma — special alcoves designed for displaying art, flowers, scrolls, and other carefully chosen objects.

We were shown three different styles: sō, gyō, and shin.

The first, sō, was the most rustic and informal. The wood was relatively rough-hewn, and the supporting pillar still had its bark.

The middle style, gyō, was more refined. The bark had been removed, and the woodwork was more carefully finished.

Finally, shin, the most formal, had beautiful polished surfaces, including dark lacquered wood.

But the really interesting part came when our guide explained how we were supposed to LOOK at the bonsai.

Although the trees were elevated on display stands, they were intended to be appreciated from a seated position on the tatami mats.

In seiza.

Ah.

Seiza.

My old friend. Or perhaps more accurately, my old adversary.

Those of you following my iaido adventures know that seiza, the traditional Japanese kneeling position, and I have something of a complicated relationship.

But I wanted to see what he meant.

So down I went, as best I could manage.

And you know what?

It made an enormous difference.

Standing up, you’re looking down at the top of the tree.

From seiza, you’re looking into the tree. You can see the branches, their arrangement, the spaces between them, and the way the entire composition is meant to be appreciated.

Same tree. Same room.

Completely different experience.

And it occurred to me that this is one of the things I particularly enjoy about Japanese arts: the idea that how you position yourself, how you approach something, and even how you look at it are all part of the experience.

A bonsai isn’t simply an object to be admired.

There’s a relationship between the tree and the person looking at it.

And sometimes, to understand that relationship, you have to change your own perspective.

Literally.

Tea Ceremony: The Memory Is Willing, but…

Next door, in the tea ceremony building, a group was practicing the Japanese tea ceremony.

I studied the tea ceremony at Green Gulch Zen Center last year, and I found myself trying to remember how to fold the special cloth — the fukusa — used in the ritual purification of the tea utensils.

Surely I could remember at least that much?

Nope.

Not a chance.

Somewhere in the recesses of my brain, there is probably a perfectly good set of instructions.

Unfortunately, it appears to have been filed alongside the location of things I put away “in a safe place.”

Sigh.

A Little Breathing Room

We’ve now got about an hour and a half before our official welcome dinner.

I’m using the time to catch up on this blog, download photographs, and generally attempt to keep my travel memories organized before they escape.

As you may recall, I began yesterday’s post because I woke up on the airplane with a memory from eighth grade and thought, “I’d better write that down before I forget it.”

Which I did.

And then forgot I’d written it down.

Fortunately, I apparently know myself rather well.

Tonight we have our welcome dinner at a local restaurant, followed by an evening on our own.

And, as established yesterday, evening is for blogging.

Although after a full day of fish markets, mushrooms, bonsai, seiza, and tea ceremonies, I may have to negotiate that arrangement with my eyelids.

Japan is off to a very good start.

I never get a percentage from any links I include – but! – if you are curious about Overseas Adventure Travel and want $100 off, call them at 1-800-955-1925 and request their amazing catalog, tell them you were referred by Sandy Shepard, customer number 3087257, and get $100 off your first trip! The catalog is what all good dreams are made of!

Japan, At Last! (Or: The Walls Actually Move!)

Tokyo, October 29-30 2026 — Arrival Day

“The walls actually move! And the ceiling itself is moveable!”

That was my very first line as the (not particularly nice) Lieutenant Pinkerton in Puccini’s Madama Butterfly.

I was in eighth grade.

Yes, eighth grade.

(I’ll wait while you catch up to the implications of that statement . . . )

Back then, our school had a rather extraordinary tradition: each year, the 8th grade was required to perform one of the San Francisco Opera’s current productions, in English, and then we would go see the actual dress rehearsal. This was before OperaText, when audiences had to figure out what was going on without helpful translations floating above the stage.

I remember remarkably little of my performance, other than that opening line and my first little solo — a toast:

“America forever! The Stars and Stripes Forever!”

And, wouldn’t you know it, I can still hum the tune. In fact, I’ve been humming it while writing this.

That experience began a lifelong fascination with opera — and with Japan.

And now, mumble mumble years later, here I am.

Japan. At last.

Getting There, in Considerable Comfort

The United Polaris lie-flat seats were terrific. They passed out slippers (which we could keep) and pajamas (which we could not), but I had brought my own.

Chad and I had carefully assembled what we called my “threshold kit,” tucked into the bottom of my puffer travel bag, containing everything necessary to transform myself from Reasonably Presentable International Traveler into Woman Who Intends to Sleep.

Among other things, this included my lovely gray Quince pajamas and silk eye mask.

I have to admit, lounging around in my own rather elegant pajamas while everyone else was wearing the airline’s S-M-L-but-really-quite-boxy light-blue versions felt just a tiny bit bougie. 😉

Dinner was good, although it included a beet salad.

Now, I KNOW about beets. I KNOW about white shirts. I even put my napkin ON TOP OF my chest, rather than in my lap.

And yet.

One tiny drop of beet juice.

One white shirt.

Of course.

Fortunately, we’re staying in Tokyo for a while, so off to the laundry it goes. ARGH!

Before settling in, I gave the purser a little box of individually wrapped Ghirardelli chocolates, with the Golden Gate Bridge on the front, as a thank-you for taking care of us on the flight.

She was VERY delighted.

I love these little boxes. They’re attractive, distinctly San Franciscan, and made of nice cardboard rather than metal, which makes them both a little less expensive than you’d expect and, to my mind, easier to recycle.

A small gesture, but a happy one.

Landing in Tokyo

I also watched a very good documentary about cryptocurrency, Everyone Is Lying to You for Money, by actor Ben McKenzie. We’d discussed his book at book club in connection with one of our earlier reads, so I was particularly interested. Definitely worth watching.

Then into the pajamas I went.

I actually started writing this while still on the plane. It was 6:45 p.m. California time, and we were scheduled to arrive around 3:00 p.m. Japan time — roughly midnight back home. (Easiest way to figure the time difference: Take California time, change a.m. to p.m., then add 3. So, if it’s 6 p.m. in Cali, 6 p.m. -> 6 a.m. + 3 = 9 a.m. in Tokyo. To go the other way, swap a.m. for p.m., then subtract 3. So, in our case, arriving at 3 p.m. meant 3 p.m. -> 3 a.m. – 3 hours . . . Midnight Cali time. Until Daylight Savings Time of course . . . Which is this Sunday 😉 )

I had awakened with that Madama Butterfly toast running through my head and decided I had better write it down before another nap erased it.

Funny, the things that come back to you after fifty-something years.

Tokyo! And a Very Long Taxi Nap

We landed, collected our luggage, and headed into Tokyo.

Yep – I purchased a Japan sticker to add to those H & I had fun putting on the hard-sided carry on – and ceremoniously added it this morning.

The airport transfer takes about an hour and a half, which sounds like a long time after an international flight.

I wouldn’t know.

I fell into a deep, apparently snoring sleep for most of it.

Very efficient sightseeing, really. Close your eyes at the airport, open them in Tokyo.

Our hotel is the b asakusa.

The room is a bit odd, especially when you consider that it’s intended for two people. There’s not a great deal of floor space, but there ARE lots of ledges and shelf-like surfaces instead of conventional tables.

Actually, that’s pretty clever. You can put things down without furniture taking up precious room.

Japanese spatial efficiency, lesson number one.

Unfortunately, unpacking brought a rather less pleasant discovery.

H’s camera — which I had carefully carried with me the ENTIRE TIME — had, once again, suffered a shattered lens filter.

AGAIN.

This happened in South Africa, too.

I have absolutely no idea HOW. The camera was never out of my possession!

GRRRRRRR.

Fortunately, the lens itself appears to have survived, but the filter has to be replaced. I mentioned this to our guide, Utako-san, whom we met at breakfast. She’s lovely, and now knows that one of our first little missions is finding a REAL camera shop.

And this time?

I am buying TWO filters.

Apparently I need a spare for my spare.

A Little Shrine, a Kitchen Street, and Our First Tokyo Evening

One of the loveliest surprises was waiting right outside our hotel.

Just to the left of the entrance is a small Shinto shrine, with a large red torii gate. At night, the shrine is chained off, but it’s still a rather wonderful thing to find tucked into the neighborhood.

A few steps farther in the same direction is Kappabashi, Tokyo’s famous “Kitchen Street,” known for its cookware, knives, dishes, and all manner of restaurant supplies.

The weather was absolutely perfect — that wonderful temperature when you don’t need to think about being too hot or too cold.

So we walked.

It wasn’t particularly late, but it was already dark. At this time of year, the sun sets around 5:00 p.m., which makes even an early evening feel quite atmospheric.

After all those hours on the plane, it felt marvelous simply to be outside, moving our legs, looking into shop windows, and taking in the fact that we were actually in Japan.

No grand monument. No elaborate excursion.

Just a pleasant evening walk, a little shrine, and a street full of kitchen shops.

A rather lovely introduction.

Today: Fish, Bonsai, and the Beginning of the Adventure

We met Utako-san at breakfast, and our first full day promises to be busy.

We’re starting with a bus tour and then visiting Tsukiji Outer Market, the famous food market. The wholesale fish auctions moved elsewhere some years ago, but the outer market is still full of shops, restaurants, and food stalls.

We’re having lunch there, which should be interesting given my allergies to fish, fish stock, dashi, and roe. Fortunately, Utako-san has been thoroughly briefed.

Afterward, we’re visiting a bonsai museum — looking at beautiful miniature trees rather than attempting to create our own — with some time for independent exploration as well.

Then there’s our official welcome dinner at a local restaurant.

And after that?

An evening to ourselves.

Although, as we all know, evening is for blogging. Ha ha.

For now, though, I’m here. In Japan.

And somewhere in the back of my mind, an eighth-grade Lieutenant Pinkerton is still singing about the Stars and Stripes.

Who would have thought?

I never get a percentage from any links I include – but! – if you are curious about Overseas Adventure Travel and want $100 off, call them at 1-800-955-1925 and request their amazing catalog, tell them you were referred by Sandy Shepard, customer number 3087257, and get $100 off your first trip! The catalog is what all good dreams are made of!

The Royal Civet Trumpet Corps

Or, Things I Did Not Expect to Learn From Filthy Musk

There are certain mistakes one makes only because one has been given too much information.

A fragrance arrives called Filthy Musk.

The official materials contain civet.

One prepares accordingly.

Something animalic, perhaps. Feral. Musky. Slightly indecent.

At minimum, one expects the civet to make an appearance.

Instead:

grilled pineapple over dark honey.

Well.

That was unexpected.


Headquarters Had Provided a Map

Filthy Musk is by BornToStandOut, created by Margaux Le Paih Guérin.

I did not read the notes before I sprayed it on.

This has become one of the rules of the Living Library: interview first, answer key second.

So all I knew initially was the name.

Filthy Musk.

Which, frankly, is already enough to contaminate an investigation if you let it.

The first spray was pineapple — but not the bright, juicy pineapple of a tropical drink.

This smelled darker.

Warmer.

Almost caramelized.

Grilled pineapple.

Underneath it was honey, but not light floral honey either. It was deep and brown, closer in character to Manuka than clover.

Grilled pineapple over dark honey.

No filth.

No obvious musk.

No civet.

I continued observing.

This would later prove important.


“I’d Like You to Meet Someone.”

The pineapple stayed around long enough to establish the fragrance’s character.

Then, gradually, it stepped aside.

But it did not disappear in the way some openings disappear — leaving you wondering whether you have accidentally put on an entirely different perfume. (I’m looking at you, Orange x Santal.)

Instead, the pineapple seemed almost to say:

I’d like you to meet someone.

And then introduced the darker sweetness underneath it.

Over the next several hours, the honey became more legible.

Eventually, I found myself thinking:

burnished vanilla caramel.

Not golden.

Brown.

Not sugary.

Rich.

Warm without becoming burnt.

And that was when I realized something else.

The fragrance was not really transforming.

It was clarifying.

Nothing important had been discarded. The opening had not been replaced by an unrelated drydown.

The fragrance was simply settling more deeply into what it had been saying from the beginning.


Patience Increases Resolution

About four hours in, I finally looked at the official notes.

Pineapple.

Honey.

Vanilla.

Caramel.

Tonka.

Rum.

And, yes:

Civet.

I was absurdly pleased.

Not because I had correctly guessed a perfume pyramid.

That is not the game.

What mattered was that I had arrived at burnished vanilla caramel before anybody told me vanilla and caramel were there.

Had I read the notes first, I could very easily have spent four hours dutifully finding what I had been told to find.

Instead, the fragrance had been allowed to speak first.

That interview gave me one of the simplest and most useful principles in the entire Living Library:

Patience increases resolution.

The fragrance had not become more complicated over four hours.

My perception had become more precise.


But Where, Exactly, Was the Filthy Musk?

There remained one small operational difficulty.

The fragrance was still called Filthy Musk.

The notes still contained civet.

And I had experienced exactly zero moments of:

GOOD GOD, CIVET.

There was no obvious animalic blast.

No furry indecency.

No sense that something untamed had just entered the room and should perhaps be asked to wipe its feet.

The darker sweetness remained the fragrance’s center of gravity.

Perhaps the musk and civet were structural — supporting everything underneath without identifying themselves separately.

Perhaps my nose had not yet learned how to recognize that particular effect.

Or perhaps something else was happening entirely.

I didn’t know.

And, increasingly, not knowing seemed like useful information.

Obviously, this required professional assistance.


The Royal Civet Trumpet Corps

Field Observation — Strictly Unofficial:

The Royal Civet Trumpet Corps was dispatched for reconnaissance.

The Corps’ mandate is quite narrow.

They do not judge.

They investigate.

They report what is actually present in the field, rather than what Headquarters has suggested ought to be there.

Their governing doctrine is therefore:

Observe.

Describe.

Wait.

Conclude later.

This is taken very seriously.

The Royal Civet Trumpet Corps is not, despite appearances, a comedy organization.

Its personnel are decorated professionals entrusted with the difficult work of olfactory reconnaissance.

Nobody in the Corps thinks any of this is funny.

This is essential.


Sgt. Percival Civet

Sgt. Percival Civet is the sort of officer who has seen things.

He is disciplined.

Proper.

Slightly weary.

He has strong opinions about honey, presumably as the result of prior service.

There are rumors of Honey Mission ’64.

The surviving assessment is (downcast look/slow head shake):

Different honey.

No additional operational details have been declassified.

Percival understands that if a briefing packet says CIVET, one does not simply march into the field shouting:

CIVET LOCATED!

That is not reconnaissance.

That is confirmation bias.


Recruit Higgins

Recruit Higgins is . . . a recruit.

Earnest.

Enthusiastic.

Question-heavy.

He is precisely the sort of junior soldier who might, halfway through an allegedly filthy and dangerous operation, look around at the grilled pineapple, dark honey and vanilla caramel, surreptitiously lick a paw, and whisper:

Hey guys . . . this is actually pretty good . . .

Which is not, strictly speaking, a reconnaissance report.

But it does rather capture the Filthy Musk experience.


Grandmother Civet

Grandmother Civet is not exactly field command.

She belongs to another branch of Civet doctrine entirely.

Her great contribution is:

Congee is patience in a pot.

Which sounds ridiculous until one realizes that it is also exactly right.

Some things do not improve when hurried.

Some things cannot be understood instantly.

And some fragrances need you to stop poking them long enough to discover what they are doing.

Grandmother Civet has very little patience for people who lack patience.

She has, however, made congee.


Standing Orders

Certain Corps priorities are well established.

Trumpets must remain dry!

(Boots are acceptable losses.)

These are not contradictory.

The Corps has standards.

A representative reconnaissance dispatch from the Filthy Musk operation might therefore read:

Pineapple confirmed.

Honey confirmed.

Vanilla-caramel confirmed.

Civet status unclear.

Trumpets dry.

Boots acceptable losses.

Operations continue.


Integration, Not Replacement

Filthy Musk usefully helped me understand something I had noticed in another fragrance: Orange x Santal.

It had taught me:

I don’t mind evolution. I mind replacement.

Its orange opening felt like one emotional contract.

Its immediate disappearance and replacement by sandalwood felt like another.

Filthy Musk did something different.

The pineapple did not disappear and hand the fragrance over to some stranger.

Pineapple introduced the dark honey.

The dark honey clarified into vanilla caramel.

The fragrance kept revealing more of the same conversation.

That distinction became:

Integration rather than replacement.

Orange x Santal felt a bit like “bait and switch.”

Filthy Musk introduces you to someone who has been waiting in the room all along.

That difference matters.


“No, Really. I Meant It.”

Filthy Musk also had a peculiar emotional steadiness.

It was not loud.

Not showy.

Not constantly reinventing itself in order to keep my attention.

Its mood became:

Quiet Confidence • Warm Conviction • Curiosity

Its place:

Late afternoon.

Polished wood.

Amber light through a window.

A glass of something rich nearby.

Nothing hurried.

Nothing demanding attention.

And hour after hour, the fragrance seemed to repeat:

No, really. I meant it.

It had said what it meant early on.

The rest of the wearing simply gave me more time to understand it.


It Occupied Space

The following day, something even stranger happened.

I walked toward the fragrance shelf and:

walked into Filthy Musk again.

Not on my wrist.

Not because I had sprayed it again.

The fragrance was simply still there.

In the room.

That felt qualitatively different from longevity.

Some fragrances last.

Some project.

Some leave sillage.

Filthy Musk seemed to occupy space.

It had established territory.

Given what followed, this probably should have been interpreted as an early military action.


HWLN?

At some point during the first hour, I began wondering what Filthy Musk might do if layered with something light and floral from Jo Malone.

I was no longer merely asking:

Do I like this?

I had begun asking:

How was this thing built?

And:

What would happen if I changed one part of the structure?

My first instinct was to experiment.

Then came the internal response:

HWLN?

Have. We. Learned. Nothing?

Observe first.

Describe.

Wait.

Conclude later.

Perhaps Filthy Musk had not finished telling its own story.

So I left it alone.

I let it finish its story its own way.

(Thank goodness.)


The Name Is Not the Territory

There is another reason I keep thinking about this fragrance.

The name gave me a map.

The note pyramid gave me a map.

Filthy Musk.

Civet. Musk. Ambergris. Rum.

It would have been very easy to follow that map obediently.

Instead, I explored without that map.

And the terrain was:

grilled pineapple,

dark honey,

burnished vanilla caramel,

quiet conviction,

and a civet that remained remarkably difficult to locate.

The map was not useless.

But it was not the territory.

The pin could only go down after I had actually been there.


Reconnaissance, Not Judgment

That may be the thing I like most about the Royal Civet Trumpet Corps.

Underneath the tiny uniforms, ceremonial trumpets, Honey Mission ’64 and wholly reasonable rules about footwear is a real discipline:

Report what is there.

Not what you expected to be there.

Not what the marketing told you would be there.

Not what the note pyramid says you ought to smell.

Not even what you smelled ten minutes ago.

Smell what is there.

Then wait.

And smell again.

Observe.

Describe.

Wait.

Then conclude.

Or, stated in the operational language of the Corps:

Do not smell the civet merely because someone told you there is a civet.

This is why the joke survived.

The Corps did not get invented afterward to make Filthy Musk more entertaining.

The Corps appeared because the interview itself had become absurd.

Headquarters said:

CIVET.

The reconnaissance party returned saying:

Grilled pineapple, sir.

And rather than assume the reconnaissance party must be wrong, we learned to say:

Interesting. Keep observing.


Field Note

★ Filthy Musk — BornToStandOut (Margaux Le Paih Guérin, 2023) Official Notes: Pineapple, honey, musk / jasmine, nutmeg, patchouli / musk, civet, vanilla, caramel, tonka, ambroxan, ambergris, rum.

An arresting opening of grilled pineapple over deep, dark honey — not bright tropical pineapple or golden clover honey, but something richer and almost caramelized.

Over several hours, the honey clarified into burnished vanilla caramel: brown rather than golden, rich rather than sugary, warm without becoming burnt. The progression felt less like transformation than clarification. The pineapple did not disappear so much as introduce the darker sweetness and then quietly yield the conversation.

Despite the name, I never experienced an obvious animalic-musk moment. Whatever the musk and civet were doing, they remained integrated into the structure rather than announcing themselves separately.

Mood: Quiet Confidence • Warm Conviction • Curiosity.

Place: Late afternoon, polished wood, amber light, something rich in a glass nearby.

Emotional impression: Self-assured without being showy. Hour after hour, it seemed to say:

“No, really. I meant it.”

A distinctive reference fragrance for the Library — less because it became an immediate love than because it taught me how much more legible a fragrance can become when I give it time.

Verdict: ★ — I respect you. You also appear to have founded a military organization.

Oh, He’s Full.

Herbert had a habit that occasionally startled guests.

People would be over. We would be talking. Everyone would be having a perfectly nice time.

And then, at some point, Herbert would simply be done.

Not with the friendship.

Not with the evening.

Not because someone had said something wrong.

He was just done talking.

So he would walk away from the conversation and sit down at his computer.

The computer was in the same room.

This tended to produce a particular expression on the faces of our guests.

Eyes slightly wider.

One eyebrow raised.

A quick glance in my direction that clearly meant:

Did we just do something?

And I would say:

“Oh, he’s full.”

That was it.

He had reached capacity.

Herbert wasn’t angry. He wasn’t bored. He hadn’t suddenly decided he didn’t like you. In fact, he might have been having a wonderful time.

He simply didn’t want any more of it.

For a long time, I thought of this as one of those Herbert things. A slightly peculiar but ultimately harmless feature that occasionally required translation for people who didn’t know him well.

Only much later did I realize he had taught me something.

I’m done now does not mean I don’t like you anymore.

Those are entirely separate statements.

This should probably be obvious.

It isn’t.

We stay at parties long after we want to leave because other people are still having fun.

We remain in conversations after we have stopped having anything to contribute.

We accept the next invitation, the next drink, the next hour, the next whatever, because saying I’ve had enough feels perilously close to saying I’ve had enough of you.

So we stay.

And then, because we stayed past full, something that had been genuinely enjoyable becomes exhausting.

Herbert didn’t do that.

When Herbert was full, Herbert stopped eating.

Metaphorically, usually.

Although now that I think about it, literally too.

(HERE is an excellent article somewhat related to this.)

There was no complicated subtext attached to it. No expectation that somebody else should notice his capacity approaching and rescue him. No need to invent an early meeting or a headache or some other socially acceptable reason for being finished.

He was simply full.

And living with someone who treated that as perfectly ordinary eventually taught me that I could do it too.

I can enjoy someone enormously and still want to go home.

I can have a wonderful conversation and not want another hour of it.

I can be someone’s ride somewhere and, when I’ve reached my limit, say, “I’m heading back. You’re welcome to come with me, but if you want to stay, awesome! You’ll just need to find another ride.”

They can stay.

I can leave.

Nobody has done anything wrong.

This turns out to be particularly useful when you are an introvert who likes extroverts.

Some of the people I most enjoy seem to possess social batteries manufactured by an entirely different company from mine. They can keep going. They can talk to three more people, go somewhere else afterward, make two new friends on the way to the parking lot, and possibly still be talking when I am already in pajamas.

Excellent.

They should do that.

I don’t have to.

And the lovely thing is that once you understand this, leaving doesn’t have to diminish what came before it.

Sometimes I leave because I had a wonderful time.

I don’t need to stay until the wonderful time deteriorates into me wondering how quickly I can get home without technically violating any traffic laws.

I can go while I still like everybody.

It took me a long time to realize what Herbert had given me with those abrupt departures to his computer.

He gave me permission to recognize capacity.

To stop confusing affection with availability.

To understand that enjoying something does not create an obligation to keep doing it until everyone else is done.

And perhaps most importantly, to trust that the people who know me will learn the translation, just as our friends learned Herbert’s.

She’s not upset.

You didn’t do anything.

She likes you just fine.

She’s full.

Because being full isn’t a judgment on the meal.

Sometimes it means the meal was wonderful.

You simply don’t need another bite.

What If the Problem Isn’t That AI Gets Too Powerful?

There is a remarkable amount of Sturm und Drang about artificial intelligence right now.

Not merely the entirely reasonable questions — What happens to jobs? How do we deal with misinformation? What should students be allowed to use? Who owns the work AI was trained on? What happens when bad actors have access to enormously powerful tools?

I mean the much larger question:

Is AI going to wipe out humanity?

And I confess that I have had a hard time getting from Point A to Point Z.

I use AI constantly. I know perfectly well how extraordinary it is. I can hand it a dense contract and ask it to find inconsistencies. I can ask it to help me identify a half-remembered historical reference, organize pages of notes, compare things I have forgotten I ever compared, or figure out why a perfume reminds me of cherry pie and some mysterious Christmas drink my father used to make.

That is astonishing.

But astonishing is not the same thing as homicidal.

The serious version of the AI-extinction argument, of course, is not really The Terminator.

It is not that the computer wakes up one morning, develops a personality disorder, and announces that it hates us.

The more interesting concern is that we could eventually build systems vastly more capable than today’s, give them the ability to act independently in the world, and then give them an objective that is not quite the objective we thought we gave them.

The old example is the machine instructed to make paper clips.

It does not need to hate humanity. It merely needs to conclude that humans turning it off would interfere with the production of paper clips.

That I understand.

I also understand the much more immediate risk of humans using enormously powerful AI systems against other humans. We have been doing versions of that with every important technology since somebody first noticed that a sharp rock had applications beyond cutting dinner.

What interests me more, though, is another possibility.

Not:

What happens if AI becomes too powerful?

But:

What happens if we become too comfortable?

And suddenly I found myself thinking about Star Trek.

Naturally.

There is a wonderful recurring anxiety in the original series about machines solving humanity’s problems a little too well.

In “I, Mudd,” the androids have reached the conclusion that humans are chaotic, destructive creatures who would be much better off under sensible supervision. Their solution is not extermination. Quite the opposite.

They will take care of us.

Forever.

Another episode, “The Return of the Archons,” gives us a computer called Landru presiding over an orderly, peaceful society in which conflict has essentially been eliminated.

Unfortunately, so have individuality, creativity, freedom, and most of the things that make a human life recognizably human.

The computer has solved the problem.

It has also solved the people.

That struck me as a considerably more interesting AI question than whether ChatGPT is secretly plotting my demise.

What if the problem is simply that we get very, very good at eliminating difficulty?

After all, almost every technological improvement begins with an entirely sensible proposition:

Why should I have to do this the hard way?

Why wash clothes by hand when a machine can do it?

Why calculate a square root on paper?

Why memorize a phone number?

Why unfold a giant map at a gas station and argue with your spouse about whether you missed the turn twenty miles ago?

These are not tragedies.

I have no philosophical attachment whatsoever to beating sheets against rocks.

And I do not believe my character was strengthened by MapQuest printouts.

Civilization is, to a considerable extent, the story of human beings inventing ways not to do unnecessary work.

But AI presents a subtly different question because what it can remove is not merely labor.

It can remove thinking.

Or perhaps more precisely, it can remove some of the occasions on which thinking happens.

That distinction matters.

Suppose a student has to write an essay.

For centuries, this has involved an irritating process. You stare at the page. You have three ideas, none of which seem connected. You write a paragraph. It is terrible. You delete it. You discover halfway through page two that the thing you thought you believed is not actually the thing you believe.

Eventually something emerges.

Now imagine replacing that forty minutes of aggravation with:

“Write me 1,200 words on this subject.”

Five seconds later there is an entirely respectable essay.

Marvelous.

Except that perhaps the forty minutes of aggravation was not an unfortunate barrier standing between the student and the essay.

Perhaps the forty minutes was the education.

The essay was merely the evidence that it had occurred.

This makes me think about libraries.

I grew up in a world where if you wanted to know something, you often had to go somewhere.

You walked to the library.

You found the section where the book you wanted was supposed to be.

And then something happened that search engines — wonderful though they are — changed considerably.

You looked at the books next to it.

You went looking for one thing and found another.

Maybe the book you wanted was checked out, so you took a completely different one.

Maybe the call number led you into a part of the library you had never visited.

Maybe you saw a title three shelves over and thought, Huh. What’s that?

And two hours later you were interested in something you had not known existed when you walked through the door.

The inefficiency was part of the mechanism.

This is something digital systems struggle with because digital systems are extraordinarily good at giving us what we ask for.

Increasingly, they are extraordinarily good at giving us what they predict we will like.

That sounds wonderful.

Often it is wonderful.

But there is an odd thing about a life optimized entirely around known preferences:

It becomes very difficult to encounter anything outside them.

If an algorithm knows what books I like, it can recommend more books like them.

If it knows what music I like, it can build an endless playlist.

If it knows where I travel, what I eat, what I buy, what I read and what I click on, eventually it can create a remarkably comfortable corridor through the world.

Everything in it suits me.

And perhaps that is the problem.

Because some of the most important things in a human life begin with:

“This isn’t really my sort of thing, but…”

Or:

“I have absolutely no idea why I decided to do this.”

Or my personal favorite:

“Well, this may be a terrible idea.”

In my sixties, I took up Japanese swordsmanship.

Iaido.

I am six-foot-one, left-handed, fairly clumsy, spectacularly unable to sit in seiza, and did not spend the previous several decades thinking, “What my life really lacks is a Japanese sword.”

There is no sensible optimization algorithm I can imagine that would have looked at my life and said:

Clearly, the next step is swordsmanship.

And yet it has become one of those peculiar threads that somehow makes perfect sense only after you have followed it.

I learn Japanese history because of it.

I notice things in museums because of it.

I re-discover things I have long forgotten because of it.

I travel differently because of it.

I’m embracing failure (or, trying to) because of it.

I understand my own patience, balance and frustration differently because of it.

I have friends I would never otherwise have met.

None of those things was the objective.

They were adjacent discoveries.

They were the books beside the book I thought I was looking for.

And that may be the part of the AI conversation that interests me most.

Not whether AI will one day become sufficiently intelligent to destroy us.

But whether human beings, presented with a tool that can make almost everything easier, will remember that not every difficulty is a defect.

There is a difference between drudgery and friction.

Drudgery is work that consumes us without enlarging us.

Friction is often the place where something happens.

You try to explain an idea and discover that you do not understand it yet.

You get lost and notice something.

You attempt to fix something and learn how it works.

You disagree with somebody and are forced to figure out why.

You read the wrong book.

You take the wrong road.

You begin something you are terrible at.

You sit with a question longer than is comfortable.

AI can eliminate an astonishing amount of drudgery.

Good.

I am all for it.

But it can also eliminate friction.

And there I think we should pay attention.

The question may not be whether we use AI.

That horse is not merely out of the barn; it is three counties away and apparently has a consulting practice.

The more useful question may be how we use it.

There is a difference between using a tool as an exoskeleton and using it as a replacement limb.

I use AI constantly, but much of the time I use it to push farther into something I am already doing.

I smell a perfume and say, “This is oddly like cherry pie, but darker. There is coffee. Something boozy. Not whisky. This drink my dad used to make at Christmas. What am I trying to remember?”

The machine can help me chase the thought.

But I still have to smell it.

I still have to decide whether I like it.

I still have to notice the thing that does not fit.

Likewise, I can hand AI a contract and ask it what it sees.

But if I stop exercising judgment and merely accept whatever appears on the screen, I have not made myself a better lawyer.

I have simply hired an extraordinarily fast stranger and stopped supervising the work.

That distinction feels important.

AI can help us think.

It can also give us a very convincing way to avoid thinking.

Those are not the same activity, even when the final document looks identical.

And perhaps this is where those old Star Trek episodes were more prescient than they had any right to be.

The frightening machine is not necessarily the one that announces:

“Humanity must be destroyed.”

It may be the one that says:

“Don’t worry. I’ve taken care of everything.”

And we answer:

“Oh, wonderful.”

Again and again.

Until one day we discover that somewhere along the way, we stopped doing a number of things we once considered essential.

Not because anyone prohibited them.

Because they became unnecessary.

Perhaps we stop getting lost.

Perhaps we stop struggling to put things into words.

why yes, this WAS generated by AI.

Perhaps we stop remembering.

Perhaps we stop wandering around libraries.

Perhaps we stop attempting things we are likely going to be bad at.

Perhaps we become exceptionally efficient at getting exactly what we already know we want.

And perhaps that turns out to be a very small way to live.

I don’t think the solution is to fear AI.

I certainly don’t intend to stop using it.

This technology is too useful, too interesting and frankly too much fun.

But I do think there is value in occasionally asking:

What part of this do I still want to do myself?

Not because I can do it faster.

Not because I can do it better.

But because doing it is part of being the person I want to remain.

Walk to the library sometimes.

Pull the wrong book off the shelf.

Take the class that makes no sense.

Learn the sword.

Get a little lost.

There are worse things than inefficiency.

Sometimes the thing beside the thing you were looking for is the whole point.

ALSO generated by AI. Cool, huh? 😉

The Great Reshelving — Postscript #2: Oriza L. Legrand

The House That Waited

There is a long, narrow burgundy box in my fragrance collection.

I did not buy it.

I did not stand at a counter and choose its contents one by one. I did not spray something on my wrist, fall in love, hand over a credit card, and carry home a set of atomizers.

Seb and Randy gave it to me years ago.

They had been invited to visit Oriza L. Legrand in Paris, not long after the historic perfume house had been brought back to life. Oriza gave them a box of atomizers from the revived collection.

And then they gave the box to me.

There were eighteen fragrances in it.

I smelled some of them. I made judgments about some of them. I wrote things like BANDAID, GETS SOAPY, and THOSE SQUARE VIOLET CANDIES?

And then, largely, the box waited.

Which turns out to be one of the best things that could have happened to it.

Because perhaps I did not neglect the Orizas so much as meet them too early.

Past Me was much more obviously a Bond No. 9 and Jo Malone girl. Fragrances that were immediately attractive on first spray. Easy to understand.

I have come to realize that Past Me was also extremely capable of making what I now think of as the Department Store Decision, even while standing in my own house.

Spritz.

Sniff.

OH WOW I LOVE THIS.

Wander off.

No revisit.

Present Librarian has developed a somewhat different modus operandi.

I now find myself interested in fragrances that are . . . different. Strange. Historically textured. Fragrances that may not be conventionally pretty and may not explain themselves within the first thirty seconds.

Instead, they make me stop.

Sniff again.

And think:

What IS that?

The Orizas have been doing that to me over and over again during their re-test.

They have been sitting there all this time.

Waiting for Present Librarian to arrive.


Except Oriza Had Been Waiting, Too

That would already be a good enough story.

Then I learned how the modern Oriza collection came to exist.

And the story got much better.

Oriza traces its history to 1720, during the reign of Louis XV. The house says Fargeon Aîné, perfumer and distiller to the French court, founded Maison Oriza; the name itself referred to the rice used in powders and creams — Oryza sativa. Louis Legrand became owner in 1811, giving the house the name Oriza L. Legrand.

Later, under Antonin Raynaud, Oriza grew into a major perfume and cosmetics enterprise, supplied several European courts, operated a steam-powered perfume factory, created a patented solid perfume in 1887, and collected international exhibition prizes. At the Paris Exposition Universelle of 1900, Oriza L. Legrand received the Grand Prix.

Then the road stops.

The house disappeared from the market around the Second World War. Hugo Lambert, one of the men who later revived it, said Oriza closed during the 1940s because of the war; other historical accounts place the unraveling slightly earlier.

Either way, this once-famous perfume house became, for most people, fragrance history.

Decades later, Hugo Lambert and Franck Belaiche-Bonniot began bringing it back.

And this is the part that fascinates me.

They did not acquire Oriza’s trademarks along with a pristine company archive containing every original formula, every bottle and every instruction necessary to start production again.

They had to look for it.

Lambert has described searching around the world for old bottles, perfume extracts, documents, advertisements and packaging. They found things through dealers, collectors — even eBay.

Piece by piece, they assembled enough of the surviving material to understand what the house had made.

For the first four revived perfumes — Déjà le Printemps, Relique d’Amour, Oeillet Louis XV and Rêve d’Ossian — they had surviving extracts as well as documents and advertising. Tiny samples of the old perfume were given to a perfumer, who then tried to reconstruct them.

Some formulas had to change because materials were no longer available or permitted; others were deliberately adjusted for modern wear.

In other words, these are not little time capsules containing untouched perfume from 1900.

They are something I find much more interesting.

Modern fragrances made in conversation with surviving historical objects.

Old bottles.

Old advertisements.

A few milliliters of old perfume.

A label.

A formula.

A box somebody found somewhere.

A fragment saying:

This is what we were.

And two people saying:

Let’s see.

They rebuilt Oriza by interviewing its artifacts.

Which makes what I am doing now seem almost hilariously nested.

The original Oriza made the fragrances.

The house disappeared.

Hugo and Franck searched for the surviving traces.

They reconstructed the fragrances.

Oriza invited Seb.

Oriza gave Seb and Randy a box.

Seb and Randy gave the box to me.

Past Librarian smelled some of it, made some judgments, and put it away.

Years later, Present Librarian opened the archive again.

The Orizas had already been reshelved once, before I even entered the picture.


The Phantom Tollbooth

Somewhere in the middle of all these interviews, I realized something else.

I was beginning to recognize the voice of a perfume house.

That had happened before.

Pierre Guillaume often seems to ask:

What if . . . ?

Jovoy often seems to ask:

How does this make you feel?

Oriza seems to ask something completely different.

Where would you like to stand?

Not metaphorically.

Literally.

Would you like to stand in a place carrying centuries of accumulated reverence?

Inside a tack room after the ride, among saddle leather, polished wood and cured tobacco?

On a damp forest floor beneath moss and low vegetation?

In an imagined 1920s drawing room containing orange marmalade, cacao, tobacco, amber incense and, briefly, one suspicious cat?

At a turn-of-the-century dressing table with a giant powder puff, silver-backed hairbrushes and the lingering possibility that Evelyn is about to discover the colonel has been poisoned?

On the Riviera on the first warm mornings of summer?

In the cold green air around a lily-of-the-valley plant emerging through the snow as winter ends?

Oriza does not merely put a character on the stage.

It builds the stage and invites you onto it.

And so — The Phantom Tollbooth.

One of the most dog-eared books of my childhood.

(Pardon the pun, Tock.)

Because that is the peculiar trick of both the book and Oriza.

They do not merely describe another world.

They open the gate and let you in.


And Then You Get to Decide Whether You Want to Live There

This is where the Great Reshelving comes back into the story.

Because being transported somewhere beautifully does not mean I need to own the transportation.

Recognition does not require residency.

That was perhaps the great lesson of Chypre Mousse.

Past Librarian had given it a heart.

Present Librarian smelled fennel, moss, undergrowth and forest floor and thought:

Yes. This is extraordinary.

And also:

No. I do not particularly want to smell like it.

The old heart may have been answering:

Did you show me something extraordinary?

Yes.

Present Librarian asks:

Do I want you accompanying my life?

No.

Both answers can be true.

A fragrance can expand the Atlas without winding up in the Cabinet.

Thank you for showing me the forest floor.

I’ll return to the path now.

Or, more succinctly:

Not really my cup of . . . moss.

The woodland fairies may keep the roasted chestnuts.


The Department Store Decision, at Home

Then there was Villa Lympia.

Its opening nearly had me online buying a bottle.

Sand.

Sea spray.

Greenery.

A little brightness.

Not “beach perfume.”

Summer, but refined.

I imagined walking beside the Riviera in the morning wearing a long sheer cover-up over a bathing suit, salt in the air, greenery nearby.

For fifteen minutes:

♥. Absolutely. How much is a bottle?

Then Villa Lympia changed.

The fresh salt-air world became sweeter. Briefly almost maple-syrup sweet.

Then came a distinct whiff of sunscreen.

Nice sunscreen.

There was still a little briny air underneath it.

Nothing had become unpleasant.

But the refined coastal atmosphere I had fallen for was no longer quite in the foreground. Now I was simply on the beach, catching the warm, familiar scent of sunscreen on skin.

And suddenly I understood Past Librarian better.

She had probably smelled that magnificent opening, said OH WOW LOVE THIS, and gone on with whatever else she was doing.

Rating: Heart!

Past Me delighted in the opening.

Present Me stayed for the whole conversation.

Villa Lympia did not lose me because it became unpleasant.

It lost me because it changed locations.

Even Oriza’s disappointments are spatial.


Memory in a Bottle, Though I’m Not Sure Whose Memory

Horizon, created in 1925, began with orange-peel marmalade, cacao and cured tobacco leaf.

It smelled distinctly old.

But not stale.

Not costume-y.

More like:

memory in a bottle . . . though I’m not sure whose memory.

I seemed to have walked into an old drawing room where a conversation was already underway.

Later came amber incense.

And, briefly, something I scientifically classified as:

cat-pissesque.

The more dignified explanation was ambergris.

Marco Polo had apparently wandered into the room, lit the incense, settled into a chair and then stopped.

Sniffed.

Looked around.

“Does someone here own a cat?”

Fortunately the cat left.

The amber stayed.

Past Librarian gave Horizon a heart.

Present Librarian gives it a star.

Not because the old assessment was wrong. Horizon remains wonderfully evocative.

But what lasts longest on my skin is amber.

And the Library already has Mitzah.

I do not need two fragrances merely because they arrive at the same place by different roads.

Horizon showed me somewhere fascinating.

I am glad I visited.

I do not need to maintain a residence there.


Sometimes the House Speaks in an Older Language

The carnations may be where I fell particularly hard for Oriza.

Royal Oeillet opened with unmistakable clove.

Then . . . a flower.

I first thought rose.

Only afterward did I remember to look up oeillet.

It’s French for carnation.

Of course.

Except carnation itself did not appear in the official note list I had.

Instead:

clove.

Rose.

Geranium.

Pepper.

Violet leaf.

And suddenly I understood what fascinated me about it.

It was almost as though someone had said:

Here. Smell this carnation. Now make it.

Not by simply writing carnation on the page.

By reconstructing the impression from pieces.

It reminded me less of an orchestra performing from a score than of a musician hearing a piece and then trying to transcribe it by ear — finding the line again, instrument by instrument, until the remembered song emerges.

Clove for that unmistakable spicy character.

Rose and geranium for flower.

Pepper for bite.

Violet leaf for something greener and more stem-like.

Not carnation as ingredient.

Carnation as reconstruction.

And there is something particularly wonderful about a perfume first launched in 1900 doing exactly that.

It smelled wonderfully historical.

Not simply vintage.

Edwardian.

Spiced flower. Old wood. Resin. Cool air.

It lasted only about three hours.

I did not care.

♥.

Then came Oeillet Louis XV.

Juicy orange, almost tangerine, immediately underlaid with something darker.

Pepper.

Clove.

(Carnation!)

The bright citrus and dark spice moved together instead of taking turns.

As it dried, something appeared that I can only describe as:

honey without sweetness.

Golden.

Waxy.

Deep.

Not gourmand.

A little powder.

And again came that sense that I was smelling something conceived in a different olfactory language from most perfumes being made today.

Villa Lympia had made me ask the dangerous question:

How much is a bottle?

Oeillet Louis XV made me ask it again.

Except this time the question survived the drydown.

I am still not entirely certain what job it has.

Maybe none.

Perhaps some fragrances deserve to remain simply because they are so specific and beautiful that the conversation itself is worth preserving.

There should always be room in a Library for a few books nobody can quite explain why they own.

Free-range shelf.

Avoiding the temptation to buy a full bottle.

♥.


And One of Them Invented Something New

Then there was Rêve d’Ossian.

Except it did not really invent a room.

That was the discovery.

Some fragrances introduce notes.

Some introduce characters.

Rêve d’Ossian introduced an experience.

My first thought was not incense or pine.

It was:

Time.

Not ordinary time.

Consecrated time.

Pine. Old incense. Beeswax. Warm wood. Candlelight.

A cathedral?

No.

An old Russian church surrounded by pine trees?

No.

A Buddhist temple?

No.

Well — all of them, yes.

But none of them exactly.

What I kept reaching for was a place where generations of ordinary people had prayed, hoped, grieved, celebrated and returned for so long that the place itself seemed saturated with reverence.

Not religion.

Not doctrine.

The accumulation of faithful attention.

One candle.

Then another.

One prayer.

Then another.

One bow.

One offering.

One waft of incense.

Then another.

Generation upon generation.

Until the place itself begins to remember.

The fragrance does not smell like a cathedral.

It smells like what faithful time leaves behind.

During this rediscovery of my fragrance collection, we have talked a great deal about rooms.

Some fragrances seem to place me somewhere almost immediately.

Taipei put me in a kitchen.

Others have led me into drawing rooms, parties, a lighthouse, even a valet’s private quarters.

Again and again, fragrance has turned out to be oddly architectural: not merely something I smell, but somewhere I find myself standing.

But this was not a room.

It was a Current.

Something flowing from before me, through the present moment, and onward after me.

The fragrance did not ask me to possess it.

Only to step into it.

And that gave the Fragrance Library an entirely new category:

Ceremonial Fragrance.

This wee atomizer of Rêve d’Ossian will come with me when I walk the Kiso Road this winter.

Not because it smells like Japan.

Not because it makes the Kiso Road sacred.

The road does not need my help.

The fragrance simply reminds me to notice.

Consecration is not making something sacred. It is recognizing that it already is.

And it introduced one more evolution in the Atlas:

The Collector asks:

What can I acquire?

The Librarian asks:

Where does this belong?

The Pilgrim asks:

How do I enter well?

There is much more to say about that.

Enough, I think, for another post entirely.

For now:

Others have come this way before you.

Now . . . step into the stream for a little while.


The Field Notes

The Great Reshelving ratings remain relational rather than hierarchical:

♥ — I trust you, and I want you in my Library.

★ — I respect you. You may stay, or your next best use may be somewhere else.

< — I understand you, but we don’t belong together.

And one small archival complication:

Seven of the original eighteen Oriza atomizers have, sometime during the intervening years, gone walkabout.

I cannot do a Current-Librarian interview without the atomizer.

So I have left those seven in the rankings Past Librarian gave them and set their entries in italics. They are not Current-Librarian reassessments; they are simply the notes I left behind the first time we met.

Should one eventually emerge triumphantly from the back of a drawer, I reserve the right to reopen the case.


Hearts (♥)

Rêve d’Ossian — 1900

Incense • Pine • Opoponax • Benzoin • Guaiac • Frankincense • Myrrh

Role: Ceremonial Fragrance

Pine, old incense, beeswax, warm wood and candlelight.

But ultimately:

the accumulation of faithful attention.

Not a cathedral.

Not a temple.

What remains in a place after generations of people have arrived with hope, grief, gratitude, prayer, silence and presence.

The first Ceremonial Fragrance in the Library.

Others have come this way before you. Now . . . step into the stream for a little while.

Past Assessment: ♥  Current Assessment: ♥


Royal Oeillet — 1900

Black Pepper • Rose • Cloves • Geranium • Pink Pepper • Cedar • Sandalwood • Violet Leaf

The opening was unmistakably clove.

Then . . . a flower.

Learning that oeillet means carnation made the structure suddenly legible even though carnation itself was not listed among the notes.

It was almost as though someone had said:

Here. Smell this carnation. Now make it.

Clove for spice.

Rose and geranium for flower.

Pepper for bite.

Violet leaf for green stem.

Carnation as reconstruction.

Underneath it was the same dark resinous quality Past Librarian had identified as myrrh.

Spicy flower.

Old wood.

Resin.

Cool air.

Not merely vintage.

Edwardian.

Poor longevity — about three hours.

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: ♥


Oeillet Louis XV — 1909

Pink Pepper • Mandarin • White Carnation • Carnation • Clove • Iris • Rose • Orchid • Cedar • Blonde Woods

Residence: Cabinet — free-range shelf

Juicy orange, almost tangerine.

Then almost immediately:

spicy flower.

Mandarin and pink pepper remain beautifully integrated with carnation and clove.

The drydown becomes darker and develops something like:

honey without sweetness.

Golden. Waxy. Rich. A little powder.

A fragrance that seems conceived in a different olfactory language.

Not particularly long-lasting.

Does not obviously fill a functional Library job.

Does not particularly need to.

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: ♥


Stars (★)

Muguet Fleuri — 1920

Lily-of-the-Valley • Green Leaves • Grass • Violet Leaf • Galbanum • Angelica • Lily • Oakmoss

Mood: Crisp Spring Morning / Winter Is Ending

My immediate reaction:

I have a whole lily-of-the-valley plant growing out of my wrist.

Not merely flowers.

Bells.

Leaves.

Stems.

Cold green spring air.

When I lived in Washington, D.C., lily-of-the-valley would begin pushing through the snow at Rachel’s house.

Those tiny shoots meant something.

Winter was ending.

I may never wear this routinely.

But in the depths of winter, when spring feels impossibly far away?

Spritz.

A small act of optimism.

Spring always comes.

Residence: Jo Malone Drawer — Lily-of-the-Valley

If I ever need lily-of-the-valley, this is it.

Past Assessment: ★ Current Assessment: ★


Les Tourterelles de Zelmis — 1913

Ivy • Black Pepper • May Rose • Bourbon Geranium • Red Peony • Turkish Rose • Saffron

ROSE!!

Then quickly, a drier rose.

Not a fresh bouquet.

More like old-fashioned rose potpourri.

Something behind it took a while to identify. Geranium accounted for some of the secondary floral character; saffron likely supplied the elusive dry-spicy strangeness I kept chasing.

More spice and dryness than lushness.

Pleasant.

Distinctive.

But the Library already contains roses with work to do.

This one does not need a separate chair.

Residence: Jo Malone Drawer — Roses

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: ★


Villa Lympia

Sea Water • Pine Needles • Sea Salt • Mimosa • Seaweed • Immortelle

The extraordinary opening:

summer, but refined.

Sand.

Sea spray.

Greenery.

Light.

A Riviera morning.

For fifteen minutes I wanted a bottle.

Then the perfume moved.

First sweeter — almost maple syrup.

Then that distinct whiff of sunscreen.

Still a little briny.

Still pleasant.

But no longer quite the place I had fallen in love with.

Past Me answered the opening.

Present Me stayed for the whole conversation.

Disposition: Travel Safely / Give Away

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: ★


Horizon — 1925

Rose • Orange Peel • Cacao • Cognac • Tobacco Leaf • Amber • Leather • Ambergris

Orange-peel marmalade.

Cacao.

Cured tobacco.

Memory in a bottle . . . though I’m not sure whose memory.

Then amber incense.

Then briefly:

cat-pissesque.

Apparently ambergris.

Eventually mostly amber.

A beautiful and convincing world.

But Mitzah already sits in the amber chair.

Glad I visited.

No need to buy property.

Somewhere Marco Polo is still trying to discover who owns that cat.

Disposition: Next Best Use

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: ★


Déjà le Printemps — 20121

Spearmint • Chamomile • Orange Blossom • Grass • Fig Leaf • Clover • Galbanum • Lily-of-the-Valley • Cedar • Vetiver • Moss • Musk

Past note: “Wild & Green Grass.”
Past Librarian’s considerably less diplomatic annotation: BANDAID.

This was an unexpected rediscovery.

Apparently, either the fragrance changed, my nose changed, or both — because this time I smelled something completely different.

The opening is unmistakably:

green.

The spearmint is definitely there. I am not an enormous spearmint fan, but here it is tolerable rather than overwhelming.

There is also a brief citrus-floral brightness at the beginning — probably the orange blossom — but it does not last especially long.

Then the fragrance moves firmly into its green world.

The fig here is not really fig fruit.

It is much closer to the green fig-leaf / fig-tree smell I recently learned to recognize so clearly in Murmure d’Été:

leafy.

vegetal.

alive.

Cedar is also obvious. In my much older notes, I had actually italicized cedar, so apparently that was one thing my nose identified clearly even then.

This time I could also pick out the vetiver, though it stayed on the greener side rather than becoming especially earthy or rooty.

Midway through the drydown, the lily-of-the-valley becomes noticeable.

That is such a particular scent once you know it — fresh, green-floral, unmistakably springlike.

The house calls this “Wild & Green Grass,” and I would agree with the wild and green part.

Grass itself, however?

Not quite.

What this smells like to me is a:

super-clean horse stall.

😉

Fresh hay and greenery.

Cedar shavings.

Crushed leaves.

Clean wood.

Something cool and herbal in the air.

Absolutely no actual horse-related scent — just the immaculate, sunny, light stall after everything has been mucked out and freshly bedded with cedar shavings.

And that is a much more appealing fragrance than the Band-Aid I apparently met years ago.

Mood: Wild Green / Clean Stable
Emotion: Freshness • Curiosity • Surprise
Place: A freshly cleaned horse stall with cedar shavings, green leaves and spring air moving through it.

Disposition: Cabinet, for now.

I am not completely certain I will ultimately keep it, but this re-test earned it another stay.

Going from:

BANDAID

to:

super-clean horse stall

is quite the rehabilitation.

Past Assessment: < Current Assessment: ★


Vetiver Royal Bourbon

“Bright & Smoky Vetiver.”

Spicy mint and thyme; Bourbon vetiver, tobacco, juniper, immortelle and iris; vetiver, oakmoss, sandalwood, leather, styrax and labdanum.

Mood: Smoking Jacket / Country Estate.


Violettes de Czar

Violet leaf, violet, iris, heliotrope, tolu balsam, leather, amber and guaiac wood.

Past Librarian’s extremely serious analytical annotation:

SMELLS LIKE THOSE SQUARE VIOLET CANDIES. MAYBE LAYER WITH ANOTHER FRAGRANCE?

Mood: Violet Candy Box / Belle Époque Dressing Table.


We Don’t Belong Together (<)

Chypre Mousse — 1914

Wild Mint • Fennel • Green Sprouts • Oakmoss • Galbanum • Angelica • Fern • Vetiver • Pine Needles

First:

What IS that?

Then:

Fennel.

Then green.

Not spring green.

Not grass.

Undergrowth.

Mushrooms.

Moss.

Low vegetation.

The green layer beneath the obvious green things.

It did not change much, though it got a bit soapy.

No woodland fairies arrived with cocktails.

Drats.

Past Librarian probably gave it a heart because she had never smelled anything like it.

She was right.

Present Librarian simply understands that:

Originality and attachment are not the same thing.

Not really my cup of . . . moss.

Travel safely.

And please take your mushroom soap with you.

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: <


Jardins d’Armide — 1909

Powder • Rose • Orris • Orange Blossom • Violet • Iris • Carnation • Wisteria • Musk • Tonka • Almond • Honey

Possibly the powderiest fragrance I have ever smelled.

So dry and powdery that I was genuinely surprised liquid had come out of the atomizer.

Not baby powder.

Not laundry.

Face powder.

An old dressing table.

A giant powder puff.

Silver-backed hairbrushes.

Cold cream.

Scent bottles.

A very cool grandmother around the turn of the century.

The sort of room in which someone named Evelyn might discover that the colonel had been poisoned.

Historical.

Elegant.

Almost unbelievably powdery.

Interesting to smell.

I may also need to wash it off.

Past Assessment: ★ Current Assessment: <


Gentry Jockey Club — 1937 / revived 2017

Tobacco • Rose • Patchouli • Leather • Vetiver • Ambergris • Sandalwood

Not leather as fashion.

Leather as equipment.

Not wood as furniture.

Wood as tack room.

Not tobacco smoke.

Cured tobacco in the barn.

This is not someone who wore riding boots to brunch.

This person has just come in from the ride.

Oriza did not ask:

Do you like leather?

It asked:

Would you like to stand here for a while?

I did.

Thank you for the tour.

Someone else will want to stay.

No Past Assessment. Current Assessment: <


Relique d’Amour — 1900

Green Leaves • Terebinth • White Lily • Frankincense • Elemi • Myrrh • Linen • Oakmoss • Woods • Musk • Surf Wax

The first spray:

rubbing alcohol.

Fortunately that vanished quickly.

Then realistic lily, green underneath it, with restrained resin/incense.

Definitely incense.

Definitely not Marco Polo incense.

As it dried:

powder.

Wax.

And, inexplicably:

baby aspirin.

Chalky.

Slightly sweet.

Still lily.

Nothing exactly unpleasant.

Nothing compelling either.

Past Me met lily and frankincense.

Present Me stayed long enough to meet the baby aspirin.

Past Assessment: ♥ Current Assessment: <


Héliotrope Blanc

Past impression:

Heliotrope. Almond powder. Almond. Honey.


Foin Fraîchement Coupé

Past impression:

Clean & Musky. Star anise. Vintage cologne.

And then:

GETS SOAPY.


Marions-Nous

Past impression:

Blonde Tobacco & Powdery Jasmine.

Past verdict:

TOO FLOWERY.


Cuir de L’Aigle Russe

Past description:

Floral & Aromatic Leather.


The Question Changed Again

Eighteen fragrances.

Twelve Current-Librarian interviews.

Six little fugitives.

And perhaps the most interesting result is not any of those numbers.

It is that I went into the Oriza box expecting to reconsider a collection.

Instead, somewhere along the way, I realized I was interviewing the house.

And I loved its voice.

Not every fragrance.

Certainly not every place it took me.

But the thing Oriza keeps doing:

Roll through the Tollbooth.

Here is a forest floor.

Here is a Riviera morning.

Here is an old dressing table.

Here is the tack room.

Here is a spicy flower from another olfactory language.

Here is a drawing room where someone has left marmalade and tobacco behind.

Here is a place where faithful attention has accumulated for centuries.

Where would you like to stand?

That is a very different pleasure from the one Past Librarian knew when she was collecting Bonds and Jo Malones.

She wanted to smell something and immediately know she loved it.

Present Librarian increasingly enjoys having to ask:

What IS that?

Perhaps that is why the box had to wait.

The fragrances did not become more interesting while they sat there.

I became more interested.

Seb and Randy could not have known, when they passed along the strange long box Oriza had given them, that some of its contents would need years before I could really hear what they were saying.

Neither could I.

But that is one of the quiet pleasures of keeping a Library instead of merely maintaining a collection.

Sometimes the book you were not ready to read remains on the shelf.

And one day, without the book having changed at all, you finally become its reader.

The Orizas had been waiting.

Present Librarian finally arrived.

  1. Rediscovered in a drawer on September 24th. Added to this blog post. Was previously one of the “missing strays.” ↩︎

The Great Reshelving — Postscript #1: The Bonds

A few days into interviewing the Bond No. 9 fragrances in my Library, I happened to be in Union Square.

My dentist is down there, and afterward I found myself standing near a small piece of my own fragrance history.

Back in the day, Saks Fifth Avenue was across from the parking garage, with Tiffany next door. The entrance I used was on the corner, and when you walked through it you did not emerge into some vast democratic field of perfume counters.

You pretty much walked into Bond No. 9.

This was dangerous.

I would “just pop in,” as one does.

Someone would spritz something on me. If I liked it, I might hand over my Saks card with the financially sophisticated instruction:

“Don’t tell me how much. I don’t want to know.”

And if none of the Bonds struck a chord?

Well.

Jo Malone was straight ahead.

You walked through Bond, past a few other counters, and there it was.

Suddenly, looking at the shelves in my house decades later, one of the Great Mysteries of the Collection seems considerably less mysterious.

I have more Bond No. 9-branded fragrances than almost anything else.

And I have far more Jo Malone than Bond No. 9.

Apparently, part of the answer to How did this happen? is:

floor plan.


The Collector

I have been calling the person who acquired most of these fragrances the Previous Librarian.

But perhaps, at this stage of the story, she was still more Collector than Librarian.

The distinction is affectionate.

Little Collector had disposable income. Little Collector liked beautiful things. Little Collector was remarkably susceptible to a good fragrance counter.

Little Collector also understood comparative economics.

Bond No. 9 was expensive.

Jo Malone, on the other hand, came in smaller bottles.

And smaller Jo Malone bottles were, by comparison, soooooooo inexpensive.

This reasoning became even more compelling in Las Vegas, while shopping with a girlfriend contemplating buying “just one more pair” of Jimmy Choos.

Place three bottles of cologne next to several hundred dollars’ worth of leather straps masquerading as shoes and suddenly:

Look at me. I’m being frugal.

Pat, pat, pat on Little Collector’s head.

But I shouldn’t make fun of her too much.

She wasn’t indiscriminate.

The evidence is sitting on the shelf.

There were nine Bonds in the Reshelving group.

Only three were full-bottle purchases.

The others are atomizers whose individual acquisition stories I mostly don’t remember. Some may have been gifts with purchase. Some I might have wanted to “try on again at home.” What matters is that I didn’t make a deliberate bottle-sized commitment to them.

The three bottles are different.

Those were Decisions.

And when I interviewed them again, all three kept their stars.


What Did I Actually Buy?

This is one of the questions the Great Reshelving keeps asking.

Not:

Is this a good perfume?

But:

Why is this here?

Those turn out not to be the same question.

Sometimes I bought a fragrance because I loved the fragrance.

Sometimes I may have bought the experience around it.

Sometimes the counter mattered.

Sometimes the bottle mattered.

Sometimes a salesperson undoubtedly “helped me decide.”

Sometimes the price itself probably contributed to the feeling that I was buying something special.

And sometimes Previous Me simply knew something.

The clearest evidence of that is New Haarlem.

I have one nearly empty bottle with five or six uses left.

Behind it is another nearly full bottle.

Plus, there’s an atomizer.

Previous Me would apparently like to make herself perfectly clear on this point.


Recognition

Seb introduced me to New Haarlem.

Years earlier, I had learned an annoying truth about perfume: many of the “grown-up” fragrances that smelled wonderful on other women smelled completely wrong on me.

Charlie. Obsession. Opium. Chanels.

I wanted to love them.

They declined the invitation.

Eventually I found Jo Malone, and with Jo Malone I learned that I could make fragrance work by layering. I could combine one thing with another until I had composed something that felt right.

I became the conductor.

Then Seb put New Haarlem on me and said:

“Try this. I think you’re a gourmand lover.”

Oh.

New Haarlem may have been the first grown-up fragrance I loved without tinkering to make it become mine.

Someone else had already composed the whole thing.

For once, I didn’t need to conduct.

I could just be the audience.

All these years later, I put it on again and within minutes thought:

Oh, I forgot how much I like this.

That is what recognition feels like.

And perhaps Little Collector deserves rather more credit than I was giving her.


The One I Remember Buying

Then there is New Bond Street.

I remember that purchase.

The bottle is red with black leopard markings, and when it was released I was told that there were only a few available and I was very lucky to get one.

I remember hesitating.

That fact alone is astonishing.

This was, after all, the woman whose usual financial-control mechanism at the Bond counter was don’t tell me how much.

But I thought twice about New Bond Street.

I also remember rejecting the even-more-expensive rhinestone bottle.

And that matters.

I wasn’t buying it as a “collectible,” or because someone had convinced me the bottle itself was an “investment,” or because I wanted the flashier, “trophy” version. If that had been the point . . . rhinestones.

I bought the regular bottle because I liked what was inside it.

While re-testing, I looked up when New Bond Street was released.

September, 2018.

That stopped me.

If you had asked me before I checked, I would have put that purchase somewhere around 2005, when I was working in San Francisco.

Not a little wrong.

More than a decade wrong.

But memory had apparently not filed the experience by calendar year.

It had filed it under:

Saks. Union Square. Bond counter. That version of me.

Not the long-married, older, “working from home” version of me in 2018.

However, September is not only my anniversary month, but my birthday month.

So, perhaps, “Happy birthday to me!” Me?

And the actual fragrance memory?

Much hazier.

When I finally interviewed it properly, I found vanilla cake batter, dry cacao, ground coffee, and something I kept chasing through nutty and fleshy until I finally landed on pulpy.

Fresh chestnut.

Not roasted chestnut.

Herbert loved chestnuts. Around Thanksgiving we would buy them fresh, cut little Xs into the shells, roast them, and crack them open.

What I smelled in New Bond Street was the pale, dense, sweet flesh inside before the roasting.

And there it was in the official notes:

Chestnut.

So the fragrance I remembered less clearly than the purchase still had something to say.

Its star stayed.


The Woman in the Shoulder Pads

Memory played another trick with Success Is the Essence of New York.

The bottle is black and covered with neon dollar signs.

From memory, the fragrance ushered in a woman in a suit with enormous shoulder pads and black patent leather stilettos, carrying a briefcase and looking over her Ray-Bans.

She walks into the room.

She doesn’t need to announce herself.

She is $$$.

I put the fragrance on.

Nope.

Success is, instead, warm. Soft. Vanilla-ish. A little spicy. Comfortable.

It reminds me emotionally of Shalimar, which my Aunt Nina used to wear—not because the fragrances are necessarily alike, but because they occupy a similar place for me: warmth, vanilla, spice, familiarity.

Apparently the shoulder pads belonged largely to the bottle.

I don’t think I would buy Success today. My taste has moved toward fragrances that “poke” me: that have something distinctive, surprising, or slightly odd enough to make me stop and pay attention.

Success doesn’t do that.

It simply smells good.

But I own a full bottle. And it appears to be discontinued. Plus, I can imagine exactly the kind of evening when I might want that particular warmth.

So it moved to the Comfort shelf in the Cabinet.


Collector and Librarian

In going back through these bottles, The Great Reshelving is not a trial of Previous Me.

I am not trying to prove that she had terrible judgment.

Nor am I obligated to preserve every decision she made simply because she once made it.

The old black ratings recorded what I thought then.

The new ratings record what I think now.

I worked out what those symbols mean in the original Great Reshelving post:

♥ — I trust you.

★ — I respect you.

< — I understand you, but we don’t belong together.

Those definitions are not rankings from best to worst.

They describe relationships.

And the Bonds turned out to contain almost every kind.

One old star became a <.

One old star remained a star but is going to Leann.

A fragrance I had never ranked became a heart even though I have absolutely no intention of buying a full bottle.

Several perfectly pleasant fragrances turned out simply not to have jobs.

And all three full bottles kept their stars.

Maybe Little Collector knew more than I thought.

Pat, pat, pat.


Straight Ahead

Saks is gone now.

Standing in Union Square yesterday, I smiled remembering my old route.

“I’ll just take a look.”

Through that corner door, up three broad marble steps, and . . .

Bond No. 9. On both sides.

Straight ahead: Jo Malone.

That geography explains rather a lot about the shelves I am Reshelving now.

And eventually I will have to deal with the Jo Malones.

Not all the Jo Malones.

Heavens forfend.

There are 75 bottles representing 59 different fragrances.

There are bottles in that collection with old hearts and stars. There are even combinations with ratings, remnants of the years I spent conducting.

Those aren’t the ones that intrigue me most.

It’s the bottles with no marks at all.

The ones I may have been talked into at a counter.

The gifts with purchase.

The multiples.

The three I recently discovered still wrapped.

Those are waiting for an entirely different interview:

Apparently I own you. How do you do?

But not today.

Today, the Bonds have finished their interviews.

And Little Collector, Saks card in hand, can finally leave the counter.

At least until she gets to Jo Malone.


Field Notes

★ New Haarlem — Maurice Roucel, 2003

Official notes: Lavender, bergamot and green leaves; coffee and cedar; vanilla, tonka bean, patchouli and amber.

New Haarlem was my EDC for years. I have one nearly empty bottle with five or six uses left, another nearly full bottle, and an atomizer.

It opens with a bright little lift—not CITRUS!, but something citrus-adjacent—before settling into a swirl of light-brown smells: coffee, vanilla, tonka, amber and cedar. Sometimes the coffee reads almost like dark maple syrup: warm, browned, slightly sticky, but never confectionery.

And it lasts. Nearly nine hours after application, I could still smell it.

Previous Assessment: ★ / Current Assessment: ★


♥ The Scent of Peace for Him — 2013

Official notes: Pineapple, juniper berries and bergamot; currant buds; cedar and vetiver.

On first spray: juicy.

The pineapple isn’t sweet or syrupy. It is more like freshly cut pineapple that is still slightly green—the kind that will be tart in your mouth rather than a Dole ring sitting in syrup.

As it dries down, the pineapple changes texture rather than disappearing, becoming more like dried pineapple. Then an unfamiliar clean, aromatic quality emerges before the fragrance eventually settles into cedar and vetiver.

A nice trip.

What I still don’t know is where this scent lives.

I like the whole journey. I just don’t know when I would specifically reach for it.

And a full bottle costs enough that uncertainty answers the purchasing question for me.

Lovely fragrance. Excellent atomizer.

Absolutely no need to gross up.

Current Assessment: ♥


< Queens — Laurent Le Guernec, 2014

Official notes: Blackberry, cardamom and bergamot; tuberose, champaca and osmanthus; musk, sandalwood, benzoin and amber.

Right away this was floral, but not a floral I recognized.

Pleasantly weird.

As it dried down, the flowers became bigger and sweeter. Eventually the closest association I could find was naked ladies: big, fleshy pink garden flowers on long stalks with no leaves, with a slightly strange edge.

Underneath was something cool, clean and faintly clinical—not literally antiseptic, but almost hospital room. Later I caught something strangely like toasted rice.

The official notes explain why I struggled. Tuberose, champaca and osmanthus are a considerably less familiar floral cloud than jasmine or lily.

Interesting? Definitely.

Bad? Not at all.

Simply sweeter and more floral than I enjoy on myself.

I know who it is now.

And I know someone more likely to enjoy it.

Current Assessment: < — Leann


< New York Oud — 2011

Official notes: Red plum, saffron and orange zest; oud, rose, orris and patchouli; musk, honey and vetiver.

This did not begin with oud.

It began fruity, with an odd spicy element underneath. Only much later did the oud become recognizable, and even then it remained soft and powdery.

The marketing copy, meanwhile, was doing considerably more work than the fragrance did on me: Cleopatra, a lovemaking-enhancing bath additive, “Green Card” oud, prowling patchouli, designated-driver vetiver and a “lingering urban-forest accord.”

My experience was rather simpler:

fruit → odd spice/floral → some powdery oud → fade.

Interesting enough to smell once.

No role I need it to fill.

Previous Assessment: ★ / Current Assessment: <


★ Central Park South — 2013

Official notes: Grapefruit blossom and black currant blossom; jasmine and lily-of-the-valley; woods.

Very floral, but in an easy, springlike, friendly way.

I got lily-of-the-valley and something gardenia-adjacent, with a brightness that reminded me of pittosporum—that sweet, airy spring-flower smell that feels immediately cheerful rather than dense or dramatic.

Several hours and a trip to the gym later, it was still very much present, moving somewhat toward soap but retaining its pleasant floral character.

And this one had an obvious destination.

My opinion of the fragrance didn’t change.

The wrist did.

Previous Assessment: ★ / Current Assessment: ★ — Leann


< New York Nights — 2017

Official notes: Gardenia, carnation and jasmine; patchouli, flowers, sandalwood and sea notes; caramel and coffee.

Pleasant enough.

The first thing I noticed was vanilla, with something sweeter and creamier around it that turned out plausibly to be caramel. There were indistinct florals and wood underneath.

It had good longevity.

But as the day wore on, it became increasingly non-descript rather than developing into something more interesting.

There is nothing wrong with New York Nights.

It is pleasant, sweet, floral, woody and long-lasting.

I simply don’t see a character in it.

More importantly, I don’t see a role for it that isn’t already occupied by something I like better.

Current Assessment: <


< Soho — 2016

Official notes: Sweet orange, petitgrain and cassis; orange blossom, jasmine and orris; moss, cedar, vetiver and amber.

On first spray, Soho had an immediate soapy quality.

It calmed down fairly quickly, but never really became more specific.

There was definitely a floral presence—eventually I thought perhaps jasmine—but otherwise I had the unusual experience of simply not being able to say what it smelled like beyond:

vaguely jasmine-y and soapy.

And that is essentially where it stayed.

Soho is not unpleasant.

It is simply indistinct.

For an atomizer, that makes the decision easy. There is no particular character here that I want to revisit, and no role another fragrance does not already fill better.

Current Assessment: <


★ Success Is the Essence of New York — 2013

Official notes: Coriander, bergamot, mandarin and cardamom; rose de Mai, nutmeg, iris and tuberose; vanilla, patchouli and benzoin.

This goes on as a soft vanilla-ish fragrance with a little spice around it.

As it dries down, it becomes warmer. The vanilla, benzoin, patchouli and spice create something almost amber-like.

The overall impression is warm, easygoing and very comfortable.

Previous Assessment: ★ / Current Assessment: ★ — “Comfort” Portion of Cabinet


★ New Bond Street — 2018

Official notes: Pepper, bergamot and lily-of-the-valley; chestnut, cacao and coffee; vanilla, sandalwood, patchouli and leatherwood.

This one took a minute to announce itself, but once it did, it became much more interesting.

The predominant impression is vanilla cake batter: creamy, soft and friendly rather than sugary or frosting-like.

At the beginning there is a little bright, floral lift. Underneath are darker notes: dry cacao powder and ground coffee.

There is also an unusual nutty, fleshy, almost pulpy quality that eventually resolves into something remarkably like freshly cut chestnut rather than roasted chestnut.

The official notes make the composition snap into focus: chestnut, cacao and coffee over vanilla, sandalwood, patchouli and leatherwood.

The overall effect is warm, creamy and friendly, but with enough texture and contrast to keep it from becoming merely another vanilla. Good longevity, too – at the eight hour mark, still has a chestnut-y, vanilla-y, friendly scent.

Previous Assessment: ★ / Current Assessment: ★